Search This Blog

Popular Posts

Showing posts with label suicide. Show all posts
Showing posts with label suicide. Show all posts

Tuesday, 13 January 2026

UNCLE VANYA - Anton Chekhov


I think I'm starting to get the vibe of Chekhov plays. It's taking me a while but I'm getting there.

There are a lot of juicy ingredients in "Uncle Vanya", and many of these are as recognisable to contemporary Aussies as they would have been to Russians 127 years ago. And a quick aside, the play's FULL title is/was "Uncle Vanya: Scenes from Country Life" which not only tells you who it's about, but also where it's been set which double as a central theme. That's quite efficient and economical naming. But to the play...

Like many family gatherings, including the Christmas (or Festivus) parties that many of us may have recently experienced, "Uncle Vanya"  features the airing of grievances and long harboured regrets, loneliness and isolation, the point of life, contemplations and reflections and assessments of wasted lives and unclear futures. And, as with "The Seagull", quite a bit of unrequited love.

In fact there are already, from my admittedly small sample of two plays, some recurring themes developing amongst Chekhov's works. Like "The Seagull" and quite possible other works that I haven't encountered yet. There is quite a bit of examination of the point of existence and happiness, a healthy dollop of middle class provincial ennui focussed on their personal struggles, in each there is a significant and revered senior outsider male that many respect and others resent for the same reason, hints of suicide. And a gun! Again! And, also like "The Seagull", this is set in a bucolic country setting where the characters are brought together. 

But for all the the similarities, this is nonetheless a very different play. So let's have a look at it.

The story

At the country property are a number of regulars, and several visitors. Among the regulars are Ivan, affectionately known as Vanya, who lives on the property with his niece Sonya and his mum ... both also present; the itinerant guest "Waffles" and Vanya's closest friend, Astrov (a Doctor). Joining them are Aleksandr (esteemed former University professor and former husband of Vanya's deceased sister), and Aleksandr's new, young and beautiful (so described in the script) wife Yelena. And a few other characters besides.

There are pre-existing tensions before we meet Vanya and Co. Inheriting his deceased wife's share of the property, the Professor has been living off the income it has provided, earned on backs of the efforts of Vanya and his daughter, Sonya. While Vanya's widowed mum Maria dotes on the professor (her former son in law) and is freely disappointed in Vanya, Vanya has a different appreciation of the Professor, seeing him as over-rated and something of a sponge. Astrov also could care less either way.

I mentioned unrequited loves... both Vanya and Astrov both hold a torch for Yelena despite the fact she is married to the Professor. Sonya meanwhile has strong feelings for Astrov. Sonya, who is described as plain in the script - Chekhov's words not mine - also feels jealous of and inferior to the gorgeous Yelena (it's ok, they become friends).

There are a LOT of conversations in this play, conversations that mostly fit broadly into the category of deep-and-meaningful diads, ruminating on the meaning of life, looking back on what's been and ahead to what's to come.

Vanya reflects industriousness versus idleness - the work he and Sonya have put into keeping the property running versus the idleness of the Professor and others. He reflects on his unrealised ambitions as a writer and desire for Yelena. 

Astrov, an early proto-green warrior, considers the environment versus industry, unfulfilled love and disillusionment with provincial life. He also offers a very Harry-Met-Sally-esque observation about how many and women can't be friends.

Sonya struggles with feeling insignificant. Yelena struggles with a growingly meaningless marriage.

"Uncle Vanya" is nothing if not contemplative.

As performed

While most of the plays I've looked at so far have improved from seeing them on stage, this may be the first exception to that rule (for me personally). I think I preferred the written script.

I found a 1991 filmed version, adapted by David Mamet no less. It featured Ian Holms (dam he's good), Mary Elizabeth Mastrantonio and David Warner (the British Actor, and not the former Australian opening bat). Warner, as Vanya, was ok, but didn't stand out for me. The entire cast was fine, and I thought Ian Holm as Astrov was exceptional (maybe one of his best works) as was Rebecca Pidgeon, who I'd not been aware of, as Sonya. Her scenes with Ian Holm were the most engaging and her final speech, which not only concludes the play but also nicely summarises a central stiff-upper-lip resilience theme quite well. And yet this production didn't grab me.

One version I really wanted to see but it is the 2020 version I could only find on Marquee TV. But since I'm fairly well over-committed to theatrical streamers with Digital Theatre, and National Theater at Home, I thought I should probably draw the line somewhere. But it features Toby Jones, Richard Armitage, Roger Allam and Aimee Lou Wood so I'm very keen to see tit.

Speaking of National Theatre at Home, I DID see another very modified version called simply "Vanya". In it, the the super-versatile Andrew Scott playing ALL the roles. Calling it a marathon isn't all that outrageous, as it ran longer than the world record for running a marathon. His ability to retain so much dialog, to deliver it differentiated characters (subtle vocal changes, changes in how he carried and comported himself and the odd prop like a tea towel, a cigarette and sun glasses). Clever dialog, and even a great subtle jibe about how one character had mostly only written adaptations, and quite a spectacle. It really was something to see and I'm glad I did. A singular performance by Scott but I don't think it did a great job of explicating or improving the characterisations and themes shown in other versions.

And there are still other versions. Some of which are:

  • "Uncle Vanya" (1970) - a BBC Play of the Month with Anthony Hopkins as Astrov.
  • "Country Life" (1994) - an Aussie version set in the outback with Sam Neill and Greta Scacchi.
  • "Vanya on 42nd Street" (1994) - another David Mamet version, this time set in America and featuring Wallace Shawn and Julianne Moore.
  • "August" (1996) - a version set in Wales with Anthony Hopkins this time playing Vanya.
Final bits

To be honest (and I feel guilty saying this again after "The Seagull" and how they are revered greats and no doubts the fault is in MY stars etc), the play itself doesn't grab me all that much. Again. I feel that multiple iterations does improve my enjoyment of Chekhov so far as I enjoy it more once I understand it.

I DID really enjoy reading the dialog, lots of clever phrasing and philosophising. And some very early ecological, green messaging. I'm starting to think that Chekhov, who also excelled as a writer in other forms (including short stories) and who was a contemporary of Tolstoy and Dostoyevsky, may be best appreciated through the prism of his words more than his creation of a staged work? Just a thought.

But I did appreciate it, the more I worked at it. It contains powerful speeches, some thematic discussions that are still timely... and the fact that it remains, like Chekhov's other works, so popular and so frequently produced as a measure of it's quality, my personal taste and limitations notwithstanding.

Materials accessed:




Wednesday, 7 January 2026

HEDDA GABLER - Henrik Ibsen


One of the things I liked about this play, even before I read it or saw it, was the title.


Even if you knew nothing about the content of Ibsen’s plays going into them, and that was true for me, you might conceivably be able to have a stab in the dark at what they might be about from the title. 


You probably wouldn’t be able to guess much, because they are complex works, but in retrospect the titles of “A Doll’s House,” “Ghosts” and “The Wild Duck” are quite symbolic of the themes and content within, and “An Enemy of the People” is even more straightforward.


But with Hedda Gabler (and the last name is apparently pronounced Garbler if a whole bunch of actors are to be relied upon) I had nothing. Nada… ikke noe (in Norwegian)… intet (Danish).


It’s a woman’s name? Maybe? So the play strong features a woman called Hedda Gabler, obviously. Bomp Bow! Close. Her name is actually Hedda Tesman… her MAIDEN name had been Hedda Gabler. But even that choice of title gives a meaningful heads up that this is a woman feeling trapped, diminished and controlled and not satisfied with the life she now leads.


I’m not sure if summarising some of Ibsen’s other pieces in my previous blogs has been useful (you can learn most of it from Wikipedia) but I’m not going to be as detailed this time. There’ll be spoilers still, but there’s so much good stuff to encounter in this play I want to leave a lot of it for you to discover.


I will start with this… I think Hedda Gabler is the stand out play of the five Ibsen plays I’ve read and watched. I liked all of them (well not so much “The Wild Duck”) but this one I feel is much more cohesive, largely the reveals and plot elements are better constructed and earned, and it’s an amazing piece of theatre particularly for the person (may not be someone who identifies as a woman) who finds themselves in the lead role.


As an aside, “Hedda Gabler” has a reputation in theatrical circles as being the female “Hamlet”. The plays of course are very different. At the very least, this is far shorter… not even half as long. And the roles are very different, the storyline very different, but each involves a very flawed lead character and this role is a standout (and a particularly brave role to write form women in theatre at its time) and so it’s unsurprising that many great and/or famous actresses have played the title role. A very abbreviated list of just some of those actresses includes:


Ingrid Bergmann, Peggy Ashcrodt, Janet Suzman, Diana Rigg, Glenda Jackson, Claire Bloom, Kate Mulgrew, Maggie Smith, Jane Fonda, Annette Bening, Judy Davis, Emmanuelle Seigner, Mary Louise Parker, Rosamund Pike, Ruth Wilson, Cate Blanchett and Tessa Thompson.


So what’s it about


Hedda Gabler is a woman stuck in a life, a house and a relationship she doesn’t want to be in. She dreams of greater wealth, luxury and position, but she is no mere tag-along Lady Macbeth. She refuses to be a victim and displays her agency at every opportunity.


She is, in turn, enigmatic, domineering, vulnerable, manipulative, spiteful and fragile. And in at least one production I watched there is quite a hint that she is battling with her mental health.


As the play starts, she is newly married and already over it. She longs for adventure, misses the prestige of being General Gabler’s daughter, and with having significant influence in life. Out of a mix of boredom, curiosity, vindictiveness and opportunity, she is more than happy to use her influence on those in her immediate proximity, mostly at their detriment.


She insults her husband George’s close Aunt out of petty vindictiveness, toys with and tortures (figuratively speaking) an old schoolmate just for sport, and flirts with two potential love interests to satisfy her ego, setting up antagonisms and conflicts as she goes.


Plot elements include her husband (George Tesman) and an old friend of his (Eilert Lovborg) who now compete for the same position, an unscrupulous family friend (Judge Brack) who has assisted the family in the past but no seeks to control Hedda. There’s an old schoolfriend of Hedda’s (Thea Elvsted), who doesn’t remember it being all that friendly and whose presence and love interests taunt Hedda, there’s a maid (Berte) that hedda has little time for and and the Aunt (Juliana Tesman) who played a large part in raising George and whom Hedda has even less time for.


Henrik Ibsen’s Greatest Hits


Hnbrik Ibsen was way ahead of the recycling and sustainability trend, reusing plot elements a number of times. I’m not having a shot at him (although guns come up a bit). In fact I am a huge fan of songwriter Jim Steinman who has been known to cut and paste entire songs and reuse them (check out Bad for Good and Nowhere Fast and get back to me). And for both writers that’s fine.. It’s their own original work after all and they can do what they like.


I really don’t want to spoil this play for newcomers, but I can say that some of Ibsen’s greatest hits are in the mix. Again, not all of these elements are in “Hedda Gabler” but some trademark Ibsen faves I’ve encountered in the five plays I’ve read or watched include:


  • Most of the lead characters HAVE servants rather than ARE servants. Four plays. (Understandable that a middle-class raised Ibsen wrote about life experiences).

  • Suicide of a key character very near the end of the book as an emphatic moral to the story. Two plays (and a third one, an assisted suicide).

  • A child born out of wedlock whose true parentage (someone the audience has already met) is revealed near the end as a plot twist. Two plays.

  • A woman leaving her husband and her children. Two plays.


Again, not saying what elements are used in “Hedda Gabler”, but I found that their use, and the user of other previously unused elements, was more effective, better scripted and better earned in this chronologically fifth of the five plays I’ve looked at.


The Play is the Thing


I liked the play from reading it, and that’s not always easy because some days your imagination and interest don’t want to come and play, but on this occasion the planet aligned. And I would have praised the play based just on that. But watching the ting come together can be a wholly more resounding experience.


As with “The Wild Duck,” I watched three different movies/videos of the play, although with that play I was hoping to see just one that I liked whereas with “Hedda Gabler” I was enjoying each so much I wanted more.


Because it’s been performed, and recorded, so often, I was spoiled for choice and so I went with options that featured actresses I really wanted to see.


The 1962 BBC Telemovie featured Ingrid Bergmann, just one of the greatest actresses of all time (personal bias… feel free to have your own opinions), along with Michael Redgrave, Trevor Howard and others. Very enjoyable… Ingrid has such almost royal presence and played the role quite aristocratically. She was still able to give indications of cruelty while seeming dignified and aloof, and Trevor Howard as the Judge was quite sinsiter when his moment arrives. Well worth a watch.


The 1981 ITV Telemovie featured Diana Rigg (who played opposite Goulburn’s own George Lazenby in “On Her Majesty’s Secret Service”, the very sexy Emma Peel in the British Avengers (go write your own blog if you don’t like my descriptions) and also a quite majestic role in Game of Thrones… so I wasn’t going to skip this version. Diana Rigg played the role not dissimilarly to Ingrid Bergmann although seemed to always have a bit of something concerning bubbling just below the surface. She played it more sneakily and more manipulatively than Bergmann, but otherwise the set and directorial decisions were very similar and it was also great to watch.


Quite literally, the best version I saw was left to last. It was a pro-shot video on National Theatre at Home performed and recorded in 2017. I felt in this version I saw the play in all of its potential and became passionate about seeing it performed locally. The stage was extremely bare… and while I’ve started to become a fan of simple staging it leaned into the “come on mate, have a bit of a go” territory. But it did work effectively in giving the cast plenty of freedom of movement and self expression.


And what a cast. Really. I didn’t recognise many of the actors (other than Ruth Wilson as Hewdda and Rafe Spall as Judge Brack), but they all seemed to find a way to stamp their characters more personally and more substantially than in the other two versions I saw. 


But it was a tour de Force for Ruth Wilson. She was hanging on to her sanity by a thread at times (her character that is). Her outbursts were bigger and louder. She was at times more charming than the others I saw (sorry Ingy and Di) and while all of them did great work with the domineering, manipulative and nasty elements, Ruth brought a whole other layer in the vulnerability stakes. 


AND huge praise for Rafe Spall who showed the most ominous and even terrifying of the Judges I saw. Man did he own that role. You could absolutely feel how trapped and fearful Hedda was and despite her being very much an architect of her own situation STILL find sympathy for her. His scene with the can of Big Tom tomato juice is very unsettling in a kind of “Reservoir Dogs” kind of way. And speaking of that film, this production also made great use of incorporate music, including “Blue” by Jonie Mitchell, “Hallelujah” (the Jeff Buckley version) and “Wild is the Wind” sung by Nina Simone


There were many staging differences (and the work is described as being Patrick Marber’s adaptation) but I don’t think there were any major plot/script changes. Just finessing. In short, this emotional, engaging, aggravating yet satisfying rendition was absolutely brilliant. 


There were other versions I wanted to see, including the 1972 version with Janet Suzman and a young up and coming actor called Ian McKellan, and the latest riff, “Hedda” starring Tessa Thompson while I expect I’ll watch soon, but if I didn’t draw the line this blog would become 100 versions of the same play in 365 days.


Final thoughts


Firstly, YES it would work in Goulburn. Could I please direct it? Actually maybe it would benefit from a female director’s perspective. Either way, I’m very keen to see it and already fan casting the thing.


This is a very strong play with plenty of bits of meat in it that keeps it relevant all these 140 odd years later. Obviously how trailblazing it must have been to have an anti-heroine in such a strong and commanding role in the way back machine, but it’s still attracting actors, still attracting audiences.


If I haven’t been clear enough, I was very impressed. 


And so ends my five-play quick visit to the works of Henrik Ibsen. I totally get the significance of his influence on realism in theatre. In several plays I found on very rare occasions a rushed timing of events leading to the denouement, or in a few occasions a slightly implausible motive a little frustrating, but these are all very clever, multi-faceted, multi-themed works. 


Ibsen was, against considerable negative publicity and public reception, forging his own path and setting theatre in a new direction. People aren’t simply redoing so many of his plays all of these years later out of kindness… they are loved, respected and they work. I’ve very much enjoyed getting to know more about Ibsen and a handful of his works… now on the Mr Chekhov (and no, not on the deck of the USS Enterprise).


Materials accessed:

  • “Hedda Gabler” – script. Available at various places including The Internet Archive.

  • “Hedda Gabler” – Telemovie (1962). BBC Telemovie available on Youtube.

  • “Hedda Gabler”  - Telemovie (1980). ITV telemovie on Youtube.

  • “National Theatre Live: Hedda Gabler” – Pro-shot video (2017). National Live Theatre production. Available on National Theatre at Home by subscription.

Monday, 5 January 2026

THE WILD DUCK - Henrik Ibsen


I’ve got to say, this play - “The Wild Duck” by Henrik Ibsen - was a struggle.

Obviously, from reading three of his other plays and reading about Ibsen, I know that he (and his plays) are venerated.

And I know that this play is regarded as among his best.

Thing is… I really don’t care for it.

And I tried. I REALLY tried. After reading it, I scoured around online to find a video of a staged performance. Then, still very disappointed, I watched a movie version of the story (a bit better), and then another movie based on the play but with significant differences (VERY good). But the play itself I found didn't quite do it for me.

My main criticism, and I’ll get more specific, is that for a play by the father of theatre realism… I didn’t find it very bloody realistic. Broadly speaking, people’s motivations seemed poorly established, plotted actions didn’t seem to follow logically or with great likelihood, several key characters are poorly fleshed out and (again, in my mind) it reduced a key issue to a throw away plot device.

The elements I liked

But I’ll begin with what I liked or thought worked.

Like the other three other Ibsen plays I’ve reviewed, the title of “The Wild Duck” does pretty good job of summarising a key theme. Several key characters but especially Hedvig, daughter of protagonist Hjalmar Ekdal, felt like a wild duck… like a creature that didn’t belong. 

But probably the key theme was that of living a life of truth versus living a lie. This is cleverly supported by the motif of blindness. Two characters are losing their eyesight, and there is a game of blind man’s bluff, underscoring the contention that Hjalmar and his family are living less than a complete life because it is based on lies that some of them are unaware of. And it also serves as a clue to a plot point, so triple threat!

Another element that I thought well was the contrasting of Hjalmar’s returned bestie, Gregers Werle, and a doctor called Relling who lives below the Ekdal’s apartment. Gregers champions the primacy of truth in all things, whereas. Relling (like Orr in catch 22) provides an alternative and believes lies and fantasies can build hope that cold hard realities may not. Relling’s discussion where he explains several of the lies he has told, to Hjalmar and Molvik in particular, were deliberately created to provide comfort.

The play returns to some of Ibsen’s previously used themes… keeping up appearances, hope and idealism versus acceptance of one’s fate, the vapidness of society events. It features the clever recurring use of symbols and motifs and even drops a few hints to points later revealed so the audience feels the reveals have been provided fairly.

I like the themes and the ideas… so why didn’t it work for me? In my opinion, it fell over in the story telling

In summary (including spoilers)

Gregers has been away from home for some time on a self-imposed exile, and catches up with his father, Hakon (the local richie rich land baron). Hakon advises that Greger’s old mate Hjalmar married Hakon’s former maid Gina, whom Greger’s deceased mum thought Hakon was having an affair with. Hakon had even helped set Hjalmar’s relationship with Gina in place, resulting in (for reasons that I don’t think were made abundantly clear in the text) Gregers, in a fit of idealistic fervour, deciding to commence a “truth at all costs” crusade.

Gregers heads off to stay at Hjalmar’s place to start hammering home some home truths, whether the Ekbal’s like it or not.

So let’s set up their home. Hjalmar lives with his wife Gina, his daughter Hedvig, and his slightly doddering dad “Old Ekdal” Living below them are a doctor (Relling) and a theological student (Molvik). Old Ekdal spends most of his time in the attic where there are animals including pigeons, rabbits and a Wild Duck that has become Hedviog’s de facto pet which she loves dearly. The duck was shot some years ago by Hakon but it survived and he gave it to Old Ekdal to look after. 

SIDENOTE: They tell the story that wild ducks, when injured, dive to the bottom of the pond/like/river and grab hold of a reed or branch to drown themselves rather than live on injured. This is used as a central plot device but I’ve looked it up and it’s not true. Myth busted!

The story from this point is more confusing with a bunch of slightly extraneous elements and I think that’s part of the reason motivations were insufficiently established and reasonable responses were poorly earned, so I’ll shorten it. 

Gregers lets his old mate know that his wife had had an affair with Greger’s dad, Hakon, before Hakon set her up with Hjalmar. The script keeps the timing of the affair frustratingly vague, but Hjalmar is upset at this secret being kept from him. Then, shortly after… and I mean unbelievably shortly after… a letter from Hakon arrives offering to pay a pension to Old Ekbal for the remainder of his days (there’s a side story that Hakon and Old Ekbal had done some wrong together for which Old Ekbal took the fall, and the jail time) AND once he passes away, to financially assist Hedvig. 

I should mention, the suddenly generous old Hakon is losing his sight, and so too is Hedvig with a hereditary disease neither of her parents appear to have. Hjalmar wonders why Hakon would suddenly want to pay for… hey, wait a second. Is Hedvig my daughter, he asks his wife. Umm, maybe? Hard to be sure, she replies. Hjalmar storms out, I can’t keep living this lie. He tells his Hedvig he can’t bear to even look at her now and storms off.

Hedvig is confused. Why doesn’t dad love me any more. He even said he wanted to kill Ducky. Enter Captain Truthypants Gregers who tells her she should make some meaningful sacrifice, like killing her duck, to prove her love for her dad. She makes a different sacrifice and takes her own life shortly after overhearing Hjalmar ask “would she lay down her life for me.”

What I didn’t like

The first thing I didn’t buy was the rapidity and largely unprompted and unearned epiphany by Gregers that he must start spreading the Gospel of truth everywhere. Was it because his dad used to date his mate’s current wife? Or even that his dad set the pair up. I read it a few times feeling I’d missed something that led to his dramatic response but if it’s there I didn’t see it.

I felt the kind of restrained response Hjalmar had when he was first advised about his wife’s affair with Hakon was in stark contrast to his sudden revulsion at his daughter when the other shoe dropped and he figured out he may not be the biological father of Hedvig. Yep, upset I get. Needing to get his head straight, I get. But his onslaught of aggression seemed pretty OTT. Still, that’s not as big a concern as the previous point though. Or the next one.

The whole final sequence around Hedvig’s suicide seems poorly assembled. Her decision didn’t to take her didn’t seem at all earned and seemed a bit of a “girlfriend in the fridge”. Let me explain. There is a pop culture term called “fridging”, “girlfriend in a fridge” or “woman in a fridge.” It comes from, of all places, graphic novels/comics where a young superhero Kyle Rayner (Green lantern) had a girlfriend written into his storyline, whom he fell madly in love with, and then in a short period of time came home to find a really bad guy had killed her and placed her body in Kyle’s fridge. 

The term has expanded to other areas of literature, cinema, TV etc to refer to the creation of a character who is not fleshed out and given no agency to then suffer or be killed as a plot device just so a major character can be affected. I feel that’s what Hedvig is to this play. And while I know very well that suicides can come undetected, unexpected and with few signs, I don’t feel this is that… this death seems to happen solely for the emotional gut punch. 

Also, the reactions afterwards are rushed and a bit odd, and the discussion (again by the increasingly heartless Gregers) just minutes after Hedvig’s death, that this will give Hjalmar great emotional and philosophical clarity and will be the making of him, and that it won’t be long before he forgets she even existed. 

I realise… I think I realise.. that Ibsen is choosing to remind us of the heartlessness of truth over compassionate lies, but I found it a ghoulish choice for the end. And I guess that’s the note the playwright wanted people to walk away with, so fair enough I suppose.

I even read up on some essays about the various themes, some of hich I understood, or agreed with… quite a few I missed completely… and I could reproduce some of their points, but these were the ones that stuck out for me.

Filmed versions

So for various reasons this didn’t sit so well with me. And I actually felt a mix of being dopey or guilty for not enjoying this more. It IS a highly regarded play. So I watched from start to finish three complete versions to see if it worked (for me) on stage.

The first I saw was the 1971 BBC Play of the Month version directed by Alan Bridges and starring Denholm Elliott as Hjalmar and a very young Jenny Agutter as Hedvig. The acting was very good, so too the staging and it was very faithful to the original play script. But I still didn’t love it for the same reasons.

The next version, working my way through them chronologically, was the 1983 Australian movie with specially imported stars Jeremy Irons as Hjalmar (called Harold in this) and Liv Ullmann as Gina. Ullman actually IS Norwegian … not sure what that adds to an Australian interpretation but she’s very good. This version was pretty close to the original. Obviously the place and time period had changed. Old Ekbaln (Old Ackland), played by John Mellion, was no longer doddering and Hakon (now Wardle), played by former Matlock Police boss Michael Pate, seemed a bit more likeable. Still, the arcs of Gregers and Hedvig seemed short of what they needed to be and those are pretty important roles to flesh out.

Almost giving up hope, I discovered that a second Aussie version existed. Called “The Daughter” and made in 2015 and featuring an all-star cast (Sam Neill, Geoffrey Rush, Anna Torv, Miranda Otto and others), THIS version redeemed the story for me. As the title indicates, it was NOT an entirely faithful version of the original play by Ibsen. But by moving things around a little, editing out some bits that added little and by building motivation into all of the key arcs this version really worked for me (I gave it 9/10, not that that means anything). Sam Neill in particular in the Old Ekbal character was even further away from doddering than John Meillion’s portrayal. Greger’s motivation made sense, Hedvig’s decision seemed more realistic… so many of the core great ideas by Ibsen worked in this rendition.

Would it work in Goulburn today?

I have used this final section to wrap up the previous reviews I’ve written. And as this is an evolving project I realise how stupid and arrogant that question is. Anything that has worked elsewhere can work in Goulburn today. Some shows that haven’t worked anywhere could work in Goulburn today. And if I say it couldn’t, there’s bound to be someone rubbing their hands together in the knowledge they could make it work, and they’d probably be right. And of course who am I to say what could work.

At the end of the day, theatre (like any of the arts we consume) is in the eye of the beholder. I didn’t love this play because I thought the playwright didn’t earn the motivations and outcomes … that some choices seemed discordant and distracting.

But this show has worked in many places, for nigh on 150 years. So yeah, it could work here. But you’d need to do a lot of script analysis, figure out directorial and acting choices that make the arcs seem less stark, jarring and sudden. And even though I’m pretty committed to letting the play be the play and not defying the writers intent, maybe shop around for the most suitable translation or consider (as people have to when they regularly shorten the 4 hour hamlet) if minor edits can allow people greater access to the central themes and meanings that are really quite striking.

Materials accessed:

Featured Post

LETTERS TO LINDY - Alana Valentine

I saw this play last night at the Lieder Theatre and liked it a lot. It's a strong and provocative piece of theatre and it was very well...