Search This Blog

Popular Posts

Showing posts with label reality. Show all posts
Showing posts with label reality. Show all posts

Tuesday, 28 April 2026

DEATH OF A SALESMAN - Arthur Miller


I recently saw Nathan Lane on the Late Show with Stephen Colbert, and Nathan is currently (at the time of writing) playing Willy Lomax in death of a Salesman on Broadway. He recounted a story about seeing the play when he was very young with a family member who was a salesman and was also not given to telling people a lot about what he was thinking... but whom said "That (referring to the play) is true."

"Death of a Salesman" is regarded as not only one of the all-time great American plays but as a snapshot of a lot of what was happening in America at the time. While now it is more of a historic look at the role of a salesman than a current one, many of the themes associated with it... the disappearing American Dream, abandonment, betrayal, society's view of aging out of usefulness, fathers and sons... are still central themes in modern life and remain as valid as ever. 

It's another of those plays regarded as a contender for the title of the greatest American play. It won the Pulitzer Prize for Drama, the Tony Award for Best Play, ran for 742 performances, has been revived on Broadway five times (and countless other productions elsewhere), adapted to film 10 times and one critic said, best on print sales alone, is probably the most successful modern play ever published. So it certainly comes highly recommended... let's dig into it a bit.

Death of a Salesman

Willy Loman is a salesman and at 60 years of age, finds his sales declining, his finances stretched, his expectations for his sons entirely unmet and his respect within his workplace minimal at best. By any of the criteria he considers, he is a failure.

[This part of the blog was interrupted by a medical situation. The following part picks up after that and attempts to be less detailed].

Willy has an awkward relationship with his kids and the kids, particularly Biff, are simultaneously tip-toeing around their relationship with their dad. Willy's wife Linda, who he berates at times, and critiques often, continues to remain steadfast by his side, defend him against the criticisms of his sons, and comforts him when he is under stress... which he often is.

Willy confronts his boss for a raise or for  less travel-based role, unsuccessfully, is forced to deal with the success of his acquaintances and their more successful kids, and begins to spiral as a result.

The play tells a tale about ageing, about failing to achieve your life long goals and expectations, about struggling with self worth, and stress, and feelings of being unwanted and useful. And that illuminates these and other themes such as the failure of the American Dream, of materialism, and society ageing it seniors. And there are very heavily emphasised that the loads that Willy carries have led to likely suicide attempts in his past. Willy is carrying a very heavy weight and as the show progresses, the weight increases.

These are good elements for a story, but what elevates this even more is the story telling technique in which Willy has living memories and fantasies in real time, enacted all around him, as he remembers and deliberately disremembers his past. Structurally and as a story telling frame, it adds a lot of interest to the story telling for the audience. These fantasies and hallucinations are only seen by Willy, and would be unknown to his family altogether if he didn't voice comments relating to his imagined experiences as was having them.

Two other narrative elements that elevate the show... the slow reveal of Biff's problem with his dad that laid the path for much of Biff's journey in life, and Willy's final resolution.

Versions is saw

Very quickly, I saw a version I hated, and one I quite liked.

As big a fan of Dustin Hoffman as I am, I thought the 1985 version he starred in was rubbish. Over-hyped and under-delivered. Hoffman was very ham-fisted as Willy, his performance seemed overly dramatic and performative, and the makeup to make Hoffman (then aged 48) look 60 was applied very heavy handedly and unrealistically. I thought John Malkovitch as Biff was pretty good, as was Charlie Durning, but overall I watched this presentation in wonder of why people think so much of it.

The 1966 telemovie, I though, was far better. Lee J Cobb was perfectly incredibly nuanced rather than continually annoying, and so his moments of hypomania seemed interspersed and earned. It also featured a star-studded cast of actors I really like... Gene Wilder, James Farentino, Bernie Koppell (yep, Dr Adam Bricker from the Love Boat) and George Segal wonderfully as Biff. This production delivered in all of the right places, making Willy's deterioration more gradual and understandable and emphasising the key themes with subtlety and resonance.

My thoughts

"Death of a Salesman" is regarded as one of the greats and I guess it is. I think for contemporary versions to work, the barrage of heavily dramatic moments might need to be dialled back, or spaced well for the key moments. In it's own context it was obviously informed by experiences of the war and the depression, and those would have provided particular insights at it's original performances.

It's a good tory and I thought Miller's story telling techniques and novel elements were well applied and integral to the story telling, to providing a fresh theatrical experience and to the understanding of the decline of Willy. 

On a very individual level, I personally preferred Miller's "All my Sons", which I watched just before this and really loved, to "Death of a Salesman", and part of that may have been due to the lack of hype around the former and the very high expectations related to this theatre favourite. 

I did especially like a lot of the dialog and quotes... especially the quotes around "Promises were made", and the one about it being a sobering experience when you realise you are worth more to your family dead then alive. These and other comments resonated deeply and there is much for ageing people in particularly to contemplate.

Due to it's fairly relentless place, it may cause some to struggle for their emotional response to keep up with Willy's story, but it's a very good story, very well told, and even these years later a pertinent and timely critique materialism and getting by without ever getting ahead for wage slaves.

Materials accessed

  • "Death of a Salesman" - script (1949). Available numerous places for free... here's a version from the Internet Archive.
  • "Death of a Salesman" - telemovie (1966). Available freely online at Youtube 1.
  • "Death of a Salesman" - movie (1985). Available freely online on Youtube 2.


Saturday, 4 April 2026

A STREETCAR NAMED DESIRE - Tennessee Williams

 

One of my kids... I won't name which one... upon hearing someone on a TV show shouting ":Stelllllla", mentioned that that's from Simpsons. Right. I mean, in some way every pop culture reference from pretty much any time in history  is "from The Simpsons" in as much as they parody everything eventually. That one plaintive cry... "Stella"... made by Stanley Kowalski is widely recognised, even by those who don't know what book, show or movie it's from, much less which character says it (and I have to say Stella's cry of "Blanche" at the end came with more of a gut punch for me. 

And I wanted to sneer at said un-named child but the fact is that, while I knew it was from Streetcar named Desire, had heard it quoted and misquoted for years, and had seen video snapshots of Marlon Brando from the 1951 film version, I'd never seen or read the play. Until a few days ago.

As with almost all of the plays on this 100 plays, it comes with wide recognition and high expectations. In a very brief overview, it's a bit overlong, well written, open for powerful and dramatic interpretation, and if you see the play through, quite powerful and bound to stick with you for long after you've seen it.

It explores the themes of reality v illusion, desire, brutality and sweeping uncomfortable truths under the carpet and the original 1947 Broadway production won for Williams the Pullitzer Prize for Drama. The film made of it four years later picked up four Oscar including one for Vivien Leigh as Blanche. And, like so many other plays on this list, those who have played the roles in productions of this play include a who's who of Hollywood.

So let's get to the play.

The Play

Just to get the title out of the way, the streetcar routes in New Orleans at the time of writing were given names that related to their destinations, including one route that went to Desire Street. To get to her sister Stella's house, she has to catch that streetcar...  which also provided a handy piece of foreshadowing 

And arriving on that streetcar, Blanche is the visitor from hell. She comes uninvited, stays in a squashed apartment for  a crazy length of time (about five months I think), is persistently demanding and loud, and continues to poke the Kowalski bear. She suffers from great anxiety and struggles also to accommodate things from her past. She is particularly self conscious about her appearance and is concerned with whether she is still capable of attracting men. 

Suffering from an extreme and extended case of cabin fever, Kowalski is completely over Blanche's invasion of his home (and he does believe very much in the home being the man's domain to rule over). He's sick of her her high maintenance, her perpetual long and involved stories, her influence on his wife, her lack of respect for him and her antagonism towards him, calling him an ape and swine among other observations. To borrow a phrase, he is well and truly sick of her shit.

Stanley finds out some information about her past, matters that he feels speak of her morality, and in that way that people do when they want to win an argument, drags in any negative details about Blanche that might get her out of their home. Sorry, his home.

While staying with the couple, Blanche also meets a friend of Stanley's called Mitch, and without allowing it to gain legs, she tries to maintain his interest in her with coquettish and flirtatious behaviour.

Reaching his limits, Stanley purchases a ticket on a greyhound bus for Blanche to use, insisting that she has to go but she avoids the conversation, avoids leaving and becomes more and more heightened as her stay there continues.

[SPOILERS]

The play has a disturbing ending. And while the topics it brings up are ones I'd like to talk about, I don't want to ruin any fellow newcomers opportunity to discover it as I did. I will, say that a lot of the play's power relies on the ending. It's very uncomfortable. Some of the final elements are more alluded to than detailed, perhaps that's for the better as it may provoke deeper discussions about the willing disbelief of likely evidence versus the drama queen that cried wolf, of unacceptable violence being swept under the carpet and trauma induced mental health issues an being believed. Without the ending it would have had far less impact for me and hit far less powerfully. 

And as the play reach its conclusion, Blanche is led away, then poker game continues and it's almost as if the world continues and nothing had happened.

The version I saw

I watched the 2014 Young Vic production pro shot shown on the National Theatre at Home, starring Gillian Anderson as Blanche, Vanessa Kirby as Stella and Ben Foster as Stanley Kowalski among others. I was always going to like Gillian Anderson's turn at the role. Scintillating and gives herself completely to the role, including a very pronounced southern belle accent. I also very enjoyed Kirby's interpretation of Stella, but it was Ben Foster as Stanly Kowalski for me that was mesmerising. At times charming and personable, and at a turn menacing, knee jerk, tightly strung, and on the edge. Foster's Kowalski was more like Russell Crowe in Romper Stomper than it was to Brando as Kowalski.in the 1951 film version. Speaking of that version, I will probably watch it some day but this was 3 hours of heavy going attention and I need to give it some space to settle.

My thoughts.

Williams is a very powerful writer. He has a lot of dialog that is more about setting the mood and establishing the patter, then he hits you with something like Blanche's comment: "I don't want realism, I want magic," and the heartbreaking revelation that she has "always depended on the kindness of strangers." Williams also includes a lot of unobvious, uncliched conversations. 

For my money though, he does go on a bit. I still appreciate the quality of his work, I just think some of the ongoing, often directionless conversations did more to annoy me than Stanley. This is coming up with a few writers, my wish for a bit more self editing, and it's not lost on me that there is come irony in that given I am prone to overwriting.

In my post on "The Glass Menagerie" I made mention that I found the repeated use of smoking as a mood setting crutch was a bit over the top and intrusive, and the heavily southern accented characters, apparently another motif of Williams', also had an erosive effect on me after a while. Ditto for both elements in "A Streetcar named Desire" as well. And having briefly looked at some other versions, it's not limited to these presentations. But just like you're going to have to get used to descriptions of Maine and the people who live and some of their regional quirks when you're reading a Stephen King book, this is just part of the well from which Williams writes.

Just like with "The Glass Menagerie," this is another "actor's play" that I believe actors would line up to perform such strong, individual characters. Form much of the play I felt like I was uncomfortably goggleboxing a real life argument with a whole lot of conversations that didn't always add to my understanding of what was going on (and I believe that's a skill of Williams... chats that aren't always plot developing but are consistently mood establishing). But, in my very humble opinion, the ending redeemed the play considerably.

It's very difficult talking about the ending without describing the ending. Suffice to say it DID have a powerful impact for me and I'm assuming many others. You can go around in circles debating whether a powerful ending is enough to carry a show (and no doubt many will disagree with my call that the show needed to be carried), but it's called a climax for a reason. It makes the show more about something and heavily underlines some themes that had already been established.

This is a great work. 

Materials I accessed:

  • "A Streetcar named Desire" - script (1947). Freely available on multiple websites including PB Works.
  • "A Streetcar named Desire" - pro shot video (2014). Available on subscription on National Theatre at Home.



Sunday, 29 March 2026

THE GLASS MENAGERIE - Tennessee Williams


Moving from "Our Town" by Thornton Wilder to "The Glass Menagerie" by Tennessee Williams proved to be a very smooth transition. Both feature a narrator/participant, a fourth wall breaking provider of exposition. Thornton Wilder "Our Town" was written in 1938, "The Glass Menagerie" in 1944 so I wouldn't be at all surprised if I found out Williams was influenced by Wilder's play. They had the same initials after all... could they possibly have been the one person? No they couldn't, I'm just tangenting to entertain myself. Which I should stop doing because I'm TRYING to keep these blogs smaller so they don't chew up so much of my time.

The story

First of all, while it's true of all of the seminal and influential playwrights I've reviewed to date that they give greatly expanded stage directions and scene summaries, I think Williams takes the cake. He writes lengthy but gorgeous, almost poetic prose to describe the scenery and backstory of characters, the depth of that is perhaps lost on audiences who haven't read the script. It's an encouragement for directors and actors to recreate the vision he has, and I'm sure many try. I think it makes for a fuller understanding of the play as the playwright envisioned it (and I'm very Team Playwright when it comes to delivering visions), but again, you'd miss those written embellishments if you only saw the play.

The Wingfield family is a family that, each in their own ways, wish to escape the life they lead.

Tom, who works at a shoe factory (is this an allegorical element about his father, and himself, walking away? You decide), is a growing lad with all of the growing pains that come with it. He wishes to be a writer but feels stifled by his circumstances and escapes when he can to the cinema to see movies. 

Tom lives with his mother, Amanda, an ageing southern belle originally from Mississippi, who always seems to be on the edge of saying "I do declare" or sipping a mint julip. She endless recounts her popularity as a young single woman and her repetition of her former status and memories is her way of escaping her reality. She feels her life now is lesser than the one she grew up in, which she wants not only for herself but also for her kids. As a result she can be quite demanding and judgemental. But her devotion to them, which is occasionally overlooked and unappreciated by the children, sadly leaves her resenting them at times (she says as much in Scene 2).

Also in the house is his sister, a shy and very anxious young woman who is very self conscious about her limp and how she presents publicly. For her escape she owns a menagerie of animals made of glass, inanimate friends that she can focus on... her favourite of which is the unicorn, which she sees as beautiful for it's uniqueness and differences from the other glass horses and other animals... a positive spin on how she feels less beautiful for her own differences. 

Tom's father deserted the family some 16 years before the start of the play and his absence is keenly remembered and noted, as attested to by his framed photo displayed on their living room wall.

Amanda continues to relive her past, remembering how she was a very popular belle of the ball with many gentleman callers (the original name of the play), and she wishes the same for her daughter. I'm going to circle back to the male callers aspect in a little while. But, while Amanda is a large, presence commanding character, quick to tell both her children of their faults, she is also keen to set up her kids, for the future, especially evident in her trying to find a suitor for Laura. 

They are essentially a family making the best of  their situation, escaping in their own ways.

[Spoilers]

After much prompting from his mother, Tom asks a work friend, Jim, to have dinner with the family one night. Despite genuinely wanting suitors to attend her daughter, Amanda steals the attention, seemingly wishing to show that she is still the most popular girl, although stealing the attention may not be the correct description as anxiety-ridden Laura stays in her room and feigns sickness.

A blackout throughout the course of the night, caused by Tom not paying the electricity bill, leaves Laura and Jim together. At first painfully unresponsive, Laura becomes more talkative and even admits to seeing Jim several times in a play, returning to get his autograph that she routinely lacked the nerve to approach him for.

Possibly prideful and emboldened from the recognition and distant fan worship, Jim becomes more engaged with Laura, telling he that she is attractive, and that her limp is minor, and that she should stop feeling inferior to people. he asks her up to dance, kisses her cheek but in the dancing accidentally knocks over the glass unicorn, her prized possession, and breaks it's horn off. She covers her sadness and gives him the hornless unicorn... equal parts a thoughtful gesture but also acceptance that it is no longer special.

From this point, Jim regauges his interest, telling Laura she is like a sister, that his feelings to her are brotherly, and confides that he is actually engaged, and that he must go. Finding out that her son had brought home an engaged man infuriates Amanda, and her fury proves to be the final straw that inspires Tom to leave his family as his father had, finishing the play on a wistful and more bitter than sweet note. 

The versions I saw

Unlike Becht's work, Williams main plays seem to be in constant rotation and there are a number of versions you can access for free or for cheaps.

The first version I saw was a staged by the Cornerstone Theatre Company in 2025. It's actually a very respectable version. No actors names are provided, so I'll just refer to them as the characters.  The mother in this version plays Amanda as a very southern, a middle aged woman. Big, brassy and attention seeking. The actor playing Tom seems a bit uncomfortable (even moreso than the role calls for), the person playing Jim more confident, and I thought the young woman playing Laura was a stand out. Her subtle shift from nervous anxiety to softly spoken and much more engaging is slow and nuanced. It's a good rendition of the play, although the music used and the way in which it's used is interruptive and annoying rather than serving the production.

Also (and here's a segue) the cigarettes used, presumably fake, are long, massive strange looking things. Here's why it's a segue. Many writers love to use smoking in their plays as short hand to characterisation. My favourite Australian crime writer, Peter Corris, has people lighting up on every second page as do many writers I like. I'm not a smoker, although I can handle the mentions in a story, but if it's that frequent it's disruptive and feels like lazy stereotyping and mood creation. The frequency of the smoking, the weird looking smokes and the actors apparent discomfort with either smoking or just smoking these particular cigarettes destroyed some of my disbelief suspension.

The other version I saw was the 1987 film directed ironically by Paul Newman (ironic, if you count the fact he played the narrator/character in 2004 production of the last play I reviewed - "Our Town"). Newman's wife, the tragically underutilised Joanne Woodward as Amanda, who plays it a bit more serious and a fair bit less broadly southern than the other version, and very delicately and sympathetically when Tom turns on her and berates her. Karen Allen (yep, Indiana Jones, Starman, Animal House etc) plays a frail and quiet version of Laura and, quietly, acts as the spine of the story. And, in one of his earlier films before he become much imitated and parodied, John Malkovich stars as Tom in an alternately subtle, sweet and gentle then angry, richly dramatic and sarcastic Tom. 

There are other versions, and it is handy to see a stage version as that's how the script was designed, but this film version helped my understanding of the play considerably.

My thoughts

It's a well-crafted story. I particularly liked how some elements are left to the audience to decide. Did Tom actually go to the movies very often, or to bars as seemed more likely? Did Laura have polio, and maybe even ASD? Did Tom not pay the electrical bills because he was saving money to leave? Was Amanda's clear flirting with Jim just falling back on old habits and filling in for the absent Laura, or would she have seized Jim for herself at Laura's expense if he seemed interested? Was Jim really ever engaged or did he pull that out as an escape strategy? I like there is room for the audiences minds and assessments to wander.

Despite this being autobiographically inspired, certainly some elements are exaggerated, edited or merged from Williams' own experiences. "The Glass Menagerie" was clearly a passion project for him, starting life as a heavily autobiographical short story "Portrait of a Girl in Glass", before being repurposed as the play "The Gentleman Caller", and then finally expanded into it's final form as a full length play. 

Williams coined the phrase 'memory play' to describe it, and even have his character/narrator Tom (a not-at-all veiled approximation of Williams, who was christened Thomas at birth before taking on Tennessee as a pen name) explain what that is. In describing this method of story-telling, Tom compares it to the work of a stage magician... "He gives you illusion that has the appearance of truth. I give you truth in the pleasant disguise of illusion."

For all of that, I didn't really get a new feel for a `memory play'. Maybe upon greater study that will come to me, but on a first run through, it seemed like a play. Perhaps the "truth in the form of a pleasant illusion" is a disclaimer by Williams that come of this has been heightened, exaggerated, left our, merged together or made up. Yet I feel that's the case with any story that is autobiographical, or semi-autobiographical. That's my way of saying that I don't feel I know any better what is meant be a `memory play' than I did before hand.

But it's a good story, and it's enjoyable, and it's well written (as I said before, including the bits the audience doesn't get to read). I did like the deployment of the narrator/character device, used sparingly and a good connector and commentator between bits. The story itself is small, in that it doesn't seek to comment on the world, or human nature to any great extent, just a well-written tale that some/many folk will find familiar and accessible. 

I think I struggled a bit, and it's not a big deal and it might just eb a case of being from a different time... I struggled with the concept of gentleman callers. And not the concept per se, so much as Amanda's expectations that there should be a regular stream of them. Was this a common thing? And how would they know to visit? Not from Laura who is essentially a shut in. I bring this up because Amanda seems a bit judgemental about it... and a bit boastful at how much better she was at attracting gentleman callers. Not a major point, but just something that isn't a thig today, and may not have been in Amanda's later years either. 

But back to the play. It's another very popular play that many famed actors have beaten a path to get to. That must count for something. It's very much an actor's play, and I could see local actors keen to bring it to stage locally. 

Again I liked this play, I liked the closeness of family conversations and frustrations. That's not a criticism, just some plays hit more than others. I thought the writing was wonderful, both the background descriptions and engaging monologues, and with this his most personal story out of the way, I look forward to what fresh ideas he has next.

Materials accessed:
  • "The Glass Menagerie" - script (1944). Available at many online sources including at Weebly.
  • "The Glass Menagerie" - flm (1987). Freely available on Youtube(i)..
  • "The Glass Menagerie" - filmed production (2025). Freely available on Youtube (ii).


Featured Post

LETTERS TO LINDY - Alana Valentine

I saw this play last night at the Lieder Theatre and liked it a lot. It's a strong and provocative piece of theatre and it was very well...