Search This Blog

Popular Posts

Showing posts with label desire. Show all posts
Showing posts with label desire. Show all posts

Saturday, 4 April 2026

A STREETCAR NAMED DESIRE - Tennessee Williams

 

One of my kids... I won't name which one... upon hearing someone on a TV show shouting ":Stelllllla", mentioned that that's from Simpsons. Right. I mean, in some way every pop culture reference from pretty much any time in history  is "from The Simpsons" in as much as they parody everything eventually. That one plaintive cry... "Stella"... made by Stanley Kowalski is widely recognised, even by those who don't know what book, show or movie it's from, much less which character says it (and I have to say Stella's cry of "Blanche" at the end came with more of a gut punch for me. 

And I wanted to sneer at said un-named child but the fact is that, while I knew it was from Streetcar named Desire, had heard it quoted and misquoted for years, and had seen video snapshots of Marlon Brando from the 1951 film version, I'd never seen or read the play. Until a few days ago.

As with almost all of the plays on this 100 plays, it comes with wide recognition and high expectations. In a very brief overview, it's a bit overlong, well written, open for powerful and dramatic interpretation, and if you see the play through, quite powerful and bound to stick with you for long after you've seen it.

It explores the themes of reality v illusion, desire, brutality and sweeping uncomfortable truths under the carpet and the original 1947 Broadway production won for Williams the Pullitzer Prize for Drama. The film made of it four years later picked up four Oscar including one for Vivien Leigh as Blanche. And, like so many other plays on this list, those who have played the roles in productions of this play include a who's who of Hollywood.

So let's get to the play.

The Play

Just to get the title out of the way, the streetcar routes in New Orleans at the time of writing were given names that related to their destinations, including one route that went to Desire Street. To get to her sister Stella's house, she has to catch that streetcar...  which also provided a handy piece of foreshadowing 

And arriving on that streetcar, Blanche is the visitor from hell. She comes uninvited, stays in a squashed apartment for  a crazy length of time (about five months I think), is persistently demanding and loud, and continues to poke the Kowalski bear. She suffers from great anxiety and struggles also to accommodate things from her past. She is particularly self conscious about her appearance and is concerned with whether she is still capable of attracting men. 

Suffering from an extreme and extended case of cabin fever, Kowalski is completely over Blanche's invasion of his home (and he does believe very much in the home being the man's domain to rule over). He's sick of her her high maintenance, her perpetual long and involved stories, her influence on his wife, her lack of respect for him and her antagonism towards him, calling him an ape and swine among other observations. To borrow a phrase, he is well and truly sick of her shit.

Stanley finds out some information about her past, matters that he feels speak of her morality, and in that way that people do when they want to win an argument, drags in any negative details about Blanche that might get her out of their home. Sorry, his home.

While staying with the couple, Blanche also meets a friend of Stanley's called Mitch, and without allowing it to gain legs, she tries to maintain his interest in her with coquettish and flirtatious behaviour.

Reaching his limits, Stanley purchases a ticket on a greyhound bus for Blanche to use, insisting that she has to go but she avoids the conversation, avoids leaving and becomes more and more heightened as her stay there continues.

[SPOILERS]

The play has a disturbing ending. And while the topics it brings up are ones I'd like to talk about, I don't want to ruin any fellow newcomers opportunity to discover it as I did. I will, say that a lot of the play's power relies on the ending. It's very uncomfortable. Some of the final elements are more alluded to than detailed, perhaps that's for the better as it may provoke deeper discussions about the willing disbelief of likely evidence versus the drama queen that cried wolf, of unacceptable violence being swept under the carpet and trauma induced mental health issues an being believed. Without the ending it would have had far less impact for me and hit far less powerfully. 

And as the play reach its conclusion, Blanche is led away, then poker game continues and it's almost as if the world continues and nothing had happened.

The version I saw

I watched the 2014 Young Vic production pro shot shown on the National Theatre at Home, starring Gillian Anderson as Blanche, Vanessa Kirby as Stella and Ben Foster as Stanley Kowalski among others. I was always going to like Gillian Anderson's turn at the role. Scintillating and gives herself completely to the role, including a very pronounced southern belle accent. I also very enjoyed Kirby's interpretation of Stella, but it was Ben Foster as Stanly Kowalski for me that was mesmerising. At times charming and personable, and at a turn menacing, knee jerk, tightly strung, and on the edge. Foster's Kowalski was more like Russell Crowe in Romper Stomper than it was to Brando as Kowalski.in the 1951 film version. Speaking of that version, I will probably watch it some day but this was 3 hours of heavy going attention and I need to give it some space to settle.

My thoughts.

Williams is a very powerful writer. He has a lot of dialog that is more about setting the mood and establishing the patter, then he hits you with something like Blanche's comment: "I don't want realism, I want magic," and the heartbreaking revelation that she has "always depended on the kindness of strangers." Williams also includes a lot of unobvious, uncliched conversations. 

For my money though, he does go on a bit. I still appreciate the quality of his work, I just think some of the ongoing, often directionless conversations did more to annoy me than Stanley. This is coming up with a few writers, my wish for a bit more self editing, and it's not lost on me that there is come irony in that given I am prone to overwriting.

In my post on "The Glass Menagerie" I made mention that I found the repeated use of smoking as a mood setting crutch was a bit over the top and intrusive, and the heavily southern accented characters, apparently another motif of Williams', also had an erosive effect on me after a while. Ditto for both elements in "A Streetcar named Desire" as well. And having briefly looked at some other versions, it's not limited to these presentations. But just like you're going to have to get used to descriptions of Maine and the people who live and some of their regional quirks when you're reading a Stephen King book, this is just part of the well from which Williams writes.

Just like with "The Glass Menagerie," this is another "actor's play" that I believe actors would line up to perform such strong, individual characters. Form much of the play I felt like I was uncomfortably goggleboxing a real life argument with a whole lot of conversations that didn't always add to my understanding of what was going on (and I believe that's a skill of Williams... chats that aren't always plot developing but are consistently mood establishing). But, in my very humble opinion, the ending redeemed the play considerably.

It's very difficult talking about the ending without describing the ending. Suffice to say it DID have a powerful impact for me and I'm assuming many others. You can go around in circles debating whether a powerful ending is enough to carry a show (and no doubt many will disagree with my call that the show needed to be carried), but it's called a climax for a reason. It makes the show more about something and heavily underlines some themes that had already been established.

This is a great work. 

Materials I accessed:

  • "A Streetcar named Desire" - script (1947). Freely available on multiple websites including PB Works.
  • "A Streetcar named Desire" - pro shot video (2014). Available on subscription on National Theatre at Home.



Tuesday, 13 January 2026

UNCLE VANYA - Anton Chekhov


I think I'm starting to get the vibe of Chekhov plays. It's taking me a while but I'm getting there.

There are a lot of juicy ingredients in "Uncle Vanya", and many of these are as recognisable to contemporary Aussies as they would have been to Russians 127 years ago. And a quick aside, the play's FULL title is/was "Uncle Vanya: Scenes from Country Life" which not only tells you who it's about, but also where it's been set which double as a central theme. That's quite efficient and economical naming. But to the play...

Like many family gatherings, including the Christmas (or Festivus) parties that many of us may have recently experienced, "Uncle Vanya"  features the airing of grievances and long harboured regrets, loneliness and isolation, the point of life, contemplations and reflections and assessments of wasted lives and unclear futures. And, as with "The Seagull", quite a bit of unrequited love.

In fact there are already, from my admittedly small sample of two plays, some recurring themes developing amongst Chekhov's works. Like "The Seagull" and quite possible other works that I haven't encountered yet. There is quite a bit of examination of the point of existence and happiness, a healthy dollop of middle class provincial ennui focussed on their personal struggles, in each there is a significant and revered senior outsider male that many respect and others resent for the same reason, hints of suicide. And a gun! Again! And, also like "The Seagull", this is set in a bucolic country setting where the characters are brought together. 

But for all the the similarities, this is nonetheless a very different play. So let's have a look at it.

The story

At the country property are a number of regulars, and several visitors. Among the regulars are Ivan, affectionately known as Vanya, who lives on the property with his niece Sonya and his mum ... both also present; the itinerant guest "Waffles" and Vanya's closest friend, Astrov (a Doctor). Joining them are Aleksandr (esteemed former University professor and former husband of Vanya's deceased sister), and Aleksandr's new, young and beautiful (so described in the script) wife Yelena. And a few other characters besides.

There are pre-existing tensions before we meet Vanya and Co. Inheriting his deceased wife's share of the property, the Professor has been living off the income it has provided, earned on backs of the efforts of Vanya and his daughter, Sonya. While Vanya's widowed mum Maria dotes on the professor (her former son in law) and is freely disappointed in Vanya, Vanya has a different appreciation of the Professor, seeing him as over-rated and something of a sponge. Astrov also could care less either way.

I mentioned unrequited loves... both Vanya and Astrov both hold a torch for Yelena despite the fact she is married to the Professor. Sonya meanwhile has strong feelings for Astrov. Sonya, who is described as plain in the script - Chekhov's words not mine - also feels jealous of and inferior to the gorgeous Yelena (it's ok, they become friends).

There are a LOT of conversations in this play, conversations that mostly fit broadly into the category of deep-and-meaningful diads, ruminating on the meaning of life, looking back on what's been and ahead to what's to come.

Vanya reflects industriousness versus idleness - the work he and Sonya have put into keeping the property running versus the idleness of the Professor and others. He reflects on his unrealised ambitions as a writer and desire for Yelena. 

Astrov, an early proto-green warrior, considers the environment versus industry, unfulfilled love and disillusionment with provincial life. He also offers a very Harry-Met-Sally-esque observation about how many and women can't be friends.

Sonya struggles with feeling insignificant. Yelena struggles with a growingly meaningless marriage.

"Uncle Vanya" is nothing if not contemplative.

As performed

While most of the plays I've looked at so far have improved from seeing them on stage, this may be the first exception to that rule (for me personally). I think I preferred the written script.

I found a 1991 filmed version, adapted by David Mamet no less. It featured Ian Holms (dam he's good), Mary Elizabeth Mastrantonio and David Warner (the British Actor, and not the former Australian opening bat). Warner, as Vanya, was ok, but didn't stand out for me. The entire cast was fine, and I thought Ian Holm as Astrov was exceptional (maybe one of his best works) as was Rebecca Pidgeon, who I'd not been aware of, as Sonya. Her scenes with Ian Holm were the most engaging and her final speech, which not only concludes the play but also nicely summarises a central stiff-upper-lip resilience theme quite well. And yet this production didn't grab me.

One version I really wanted to see but it is the 2020 version I could only find on Marquee TV. But since I'm fairly well over-committed to theatrical streamers with Digital Theatre, and National Theater at Home, I thought I should probably draw the line somewhere. But it features Toby Jones, Richard Armitage, Roger Allam and Aimee Lou Wood so I'm very keen to see tit.

Speaking of National Theatre at Home, I DID see another very modified version called simply "Vanya". In it, the the super-versatile Andrew Scott playing ALL the roles. Calling it a marathon isn't all that outrageous, as it ran longer than the world record for running a marathon. His ability to retain so much dialog, to deliver it differentiated characters (subtle vocal changes, changes in how he carried and comported himself and the odd prop like a tea towel, a cigarette and sun glasses). Clever dialog, and even a great subtle jibe about how one character had mostly only written adaptations, and quite a spectacle. It really was something to see and I'm glad I did. A singular performance by Scott but I don't think it did a great job of explicating or improving the characterisations and themes shown in other versions.

And there are still other versions. Some of which are:

  • "Uncle Vanya" (1970) - a BBC Play of the Month with Anthony Hopkins as Astrov.
  • "Country Life" (1994) - an Aussie version set in the outback with Sam Neill and Greta Scacchi.
  • "Vanya on 42nd Street" (1994) - another David Mamet version, this time set in America and featuring Wallace Shawn and Julianne Moore.
  • "August" (1996) - a version set in Wales with Anthony Hopkins this time playing Vanya.
Final bits

To be honest (and I feel guilty saying this again after "The Seagull" and how they are revered greats and no doubts the fault is in MY stars etc), the play itself doesn't grab me all that much. Again. I feel that multiple iterations does improve my enjoyment of Chekhov so far as I enjoy it more once I understand it.

I DID really enjoy reading the dialog, lots of clever phrasing and philosophising. And some very early ecological, green messaging. I'm starting to think that Chekhov, who also excelled as a writer in other forms (including short stories) and who was a contemporary of Tolstoy and Dostoyevsky, may be best appreciated through the prism of his words more than his creation of a staged work? Just a thought.

But I did appreciate it, the more I worked at it. It contains powerful speeches, some thematic discussions that are still timely... and the fact that it remains, like Chekhov's other works, so popular and so frequently produced as a measure of it's quality, my personal taste and limitations notwithstanding.

Materials accessed:




Featured Post

LETTERS TO LINDY - Alana Valentine

I saw this play last night at the Lieder Theatre and liked it a lot. It's a strong and provocative piece of theatre and it was very well...