Search This Blog

Popular Posts

Showing posts with label Courtroom. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Courtroom. Show all posts

Monday, 8 June 2026

INTER ALIA - Suzie Miller

It's been a big weekend for me regarding Suzie Miller plays. It feels a little like cramming for a test at the last minute, but it has its advantages. The details remain fresher in your memory and the writer's techniques, story telling devices and frames are easier to remember, to contrast and to compare.

The quick take... "Inter Alia" is a very good play. It's cleverly written and follows some of the same ground both in terms of style and message as "Prima Facie" while still being its own individual piece of theatre. I didn't like it as much as "Prima Facie", and so what you may ask. Each show is unique and independent of others, it's not a competition, comparisons are odious etc etc. It's just that playwright Suzie Miller has hinted that these two plays form the first two parts of a loose trilogy so making connections isn't that strange.

"I've looked at it from the complainant's side (Prima Facie), now from the family's side (Inter Alia)... the next one will be another portal again," Miller told the Guardian in September 2025. 

A couple of things. I do like the visual and philosophical link of using latin two-word phrases for these loosely related plays ... and as long as she can keep her hands off the latin phrase Vox Populi for the third part, she and I will have no beef. But even without Miller's acknowledgement that these are sort of companion pieces, a viewer would pretty easily come to the same conclusion. 

The opening, consisting of the lead character dissecting a court case from a specific viewpoint, could be a photostat from it's slightly older sibling, some of the loose festivity vibe carries over... but I'm getting ahead of myself. back to the play.

Inter Alia

"Inter Alia" is another legal drama from Suzie Miller whose combined experiences of legal background and training and writing serve her well for both ideas and process detail. Whereas "Prima Facie" is told from the viewpoint of a senior barrister, Inter Alia is told from the viewpoint of a judge... Jessica Parks.

We are given to understand that Jessica has a strong moral base from her exposition to the audience. She cares about the witnesses and tries to ensure they are not mistreated by the process. But she is also a conflicted parent, trying to manage a home life around professional career with all of the guilts and frustrations that can entail.

Early in the play she briefly suspends the case before her to answer an urgent call from her son, Harry, who is struggling with the almost unsolvable problem of not being able to find his shirt. She helps with that, and in the process of explaining away how she manages it all, she shares with the audience memories of parenting moments with young Harry.

Then it's back to the court case.

Jessica has a happy home life alongside who son and husband Michael, also a member of the legal profession. They are cosy-cute, enjoy each others company and appear to be reliable supports for each other. She is at times a bit of a nosy mum... nothing terribly weird about that... but she cares, it's evident and part of what matters to her.

The play gives us a bit of her fund side as well. Singing at a karaoke... rocking it out... and having some raunchy lounge-room connubials with hubby after a party at their home.

And then, it hits. The dramatic centrepoint of the play... and again, there will be spoilers.

Harry has attended a party... the girl he likes is no longer talking to him and apparently has been nasty about him online. Awkward stuff for a mum to navigate. But as that expands, we find that harry has been charged with the rape of this girl, and now we're of to the races.

The parents have slightly different takes on the matter and that leads to quite a bit of tension. While Jessica loves and trusts her son unconditionally, she also wants to check if there is ANY chance his actions could be interpreted as rape... was consent gained unambiguously, did he treat the young woman respectfully. Dad, though not entirely on another page, wants to ensure that Harry is entirely covered from a legal perspective, not wanting to dig too deeply for the finer details.

As the investigating and legal proceedings continue, eventually news services link Jessica with the sons case and there is plenty of questioning through the media... traditional and social...on whether she is a fit and proper person to adjudicate over legal matters. But most difficult is a heart to heart she has with her son.

My thoughts

Again, it's a very good play. The subject matter of consent and the vague adaptations people cloak that concept in is very much part of a crucial ongoing current conversation. The TV series "Adolescence" handled it brilliantly... the idea of a young man charged with a horrible crime, and parents trying to find ways to accommodate that information into the young man they know. And sadly the answer is simple... rapists, predators and abusers can be and often are people that appear in other ways quite nice.

But I have to admit that I am stuck with this comparison in my head between "Inter Alia" and "Prima Facie" which I know is unfair and irrelevant, and they are two different plays, and comparisons are odious, yada yada yada... and I think my thoughts on this are actually useful in my assessment of this play.

Firstly, I saw "Prima Facie" live in a wonderful theatre amidst audience reactions that elevated the experience. Possibly that provided an unfair advantage.

Also, there were tropes and methods and story telling techniques in "Prima Facie" that I noticed again in "Inter Alia", meaning they were fresher and more novel and more able to spring surprises in the former than in the latter. If I'd seen "Inter Alia" first, it may have been a different story.

And the third point that comes to mind is the performance. And just like comparing plays, how do you compare actors. You're Gandhi was so much better than that guy's Goering? A good part can do so much and I thought the part of Tess was a better part than Jess (yes, I noticed that quirk too... I'm expecting Bess or old Cec in the final part of the trilogy).

Now, forgetting the "seeing it live part", I did find some parts of the format of the show a bit repeated, or unoriginal. As mentioned, the blow by blow dissecting of things happening in the court room is in both shows, and obviously I found it fresher the first time around in "Prima Facie". 

Also, from seeing the earlier of Miller's plays, I was more focused on the seemingly unimportant background information and how, like Chekhov's gun, it was never wasted and would come back. The party? Why aren't you and your girlfriend talking? The scratch? I'm not Sherlock (no shit) but I saw it coming a long way off and began to intellectualise (not always a good thing mid-play) how that was the intent of the play, to present a similar story from a different perspective. That guessing where it's going thing is not necessarily unwanted but I enjoyed being snuck up on the first time around.

And this part I feel a bit guilty saying. I'm a big Rosamund Pike fan (my stand out memory was from "World's End", "Wrath of the Titans" and "Gone Girl") but I didn't love her in this role. And, AGAIN, it's partly by comparison with Sheridan Harbridge from "Prima Facie", and they're different roles, for God's sake, and different bloody plays and who the hell am I to sit in judgement of such a wonderful actress.

I just don't feel she delivered enough variance in the light and shade department. Very god in the frantic, worried, stressed shade area. A bit les sin the light. And yep, "Prima Facie" offered quite a lot of quirk, and sass, and fun and Sheridan absolutely chewed it up. But there's also moments in the "Inter Alia"... the karaoke, the couch-sex sessions, where I didn't get the same sense of letting go and vulnerability or the connection with the audience to the same degree.

BUT what do I know. No doubt the playwright's vision and intent was to not show a carbon copy of Tess, and a more harried and put-upon professional woman/mum and she nails that.

They ARE very different plays. "Inter Alia" is NOT a one hander, with hubby and son also in the scenes. The stage has a bit more going on and is less stark and finite. The sound is completely different with a bit more rocking out going on. It addresses such an important topic and, like Adolescence, drums it home more effectively by taking a seemingly clean living "nice " boy from a nice home and revealing the horrible thing he did. And I feel guilty for finding fault in it but the simple fact is I didnt walk away as wowed as I did with "Prima Facie" so this lengthy collection of words is largely trying to figure out why.

I would definitely pay to see it live, and definitely reckon it could be delivered brilliantly in Goulburn.

Materials accessed


Sunday, 7 June 2026

PRIMA FACIE - Suzie Miller


Just under 24 hours ago I saw this play live at the Ros Packer Theatre in Sydney, and it was amazing.

I am going to try and stick to my resolution of much shorter blog posts but that still leaves a bunch of things to say.

Firstly, I want to mention this in passing. It was my first visit to the Ros Packer Theatre and out of it, The Wharf Theatre and the Belvoir, it's easily my favourite, at least in how it's configured and how the others were when I saw them. It's a traditional theatre orientation and it turns out that's my preference. I think.

But to Prima Facie

Some background

Prima Facie started it's life in very recent times (2019) at the Stable Theatre in Sydney. That original production was directed by Lee Lewis and starred Sheridan Harbridge in the lead (and only) role and the show was a big winner with the Awgie (Australian Writer's Guild) Awards..

From there the play continued to gain momentum and popularity. It toured Melbourne, then Adelaide and then Perth. It then took wing and was performed at the Harold Pinter Theatre on the West End with Jodie Comer playing Tessa and THAT production won Best Play and Best Actress at the Olivier Awards, and Best Play, Best Actress an Best Graphic Design at the WhatsOnStage Awards.

It then went to Broadway (again with Jodie Comer who won Best Actress at the Tonys and a bunch of other awards). Despite being only seven years old, it has already been performed in over 50 countries and in more than 30 languages.

I say this up front to establish that the play is worth assessing not only as a great Australian play, but a great modern play full stop. 

The Play

Prima Facie is a one woman play told from the perspectives and experiences of top flight barrister Tessa Ensler.

Two things that hit me instantly. Tessa is confident, she's fun and she's sassy, and the sound design absolutely pairs beautifully with the spoken word and deliver... each beat emphasised and underscored.

As with most if not all one handers, the story involves fourth considerable/total wall breaking. Tessa is talking to us. It starts with her divulging the tricks of her craft... the ways she lures unsuspecting witnesses into giving up information that they have no interest in giving up and which can potentially cause them nothing but grief. It

It's a tactical process akin to fishing... allow a bit of line, pull in a little, and let it play. She feigns confusion to lull a little extra misplaced confidence, does her best to appear non-threatening and easily overlooked, and then... POW. A master class I would imagine for up and coming barristers and certainly a riveting Ted's talk for a willing audience.

And so it goes for almost the first hour of the 90 minute play. It's like a day in the life, or a few weeks in the life of barrister Tessa. Her family life, her professional goals, her loves and dating misadventures... it's bloody engaging and entertaining just on that level... even if something more didn't lurk just around the corner.

But something did lurk. And this next bit is a spoiler I guess, although most promotions make it clear that this is a central topic of the play.

A date moves rapidly from consensual sex to forced and painful rape turns Tessa's life upside down. The date, a guy she liked and had already had sex with before, is a workmate. She is torn about whether she should report the case to police, knowing it will be complicated by previous consensual sex, by the fact it is a workmate... and mostly by the fact that she knows first hand how tough the system is ... how tough she has PERSONALLY made it for those who have experienced, and claimed sexual assault.

The play completely changes gear at this point... and if you are like me and walked into the play with no knowledge of the subject matter, it is a powerful switch and suddenly all of the previous advice about how she has tripped people over, how she liked this guy... so many elements become clearly more than accidental and interesting story telling and crucial threads.

I that final section, screens in the background guide the audience between time zones in the trial with the simple words THEN, NOW and AFTER displayed. All the time with graduated soundtrack, adjusting to the moments and lighting that matched them equally. In a one hander, lighting and sound are almost characters and in this play they definitely displayed Tessa's experience around her.

Thanks to adjournments and other legal processes, It takes Tessa 760 days to finally have her case heard. Things DO become difficult at work. Tessa finds herself doing so many of the things that she has critiqued clients doing. She over-speaks, becomes emotional, and the biggest crime of them all, becomes confused and unconvincing.

And the big whammy comes in the form of the motive the defence lawyers accuse her of. I don't want to spoil that one.

My thoughts

This is a stellar performance and it is so bloody enjoyable knowing that the actress, Sheridan Harbridge, and the director, Lee Lewis, have been given the chance to present a show that they originated and that since has become renowned and beloved. I imagine it's a very different experience to presenting it when it was largely unknown and finding its feet.

I know there are phrases that are overused in theatre, and I know that I am an occasional offender, so here I go again.

The phrase tour de force gets used a lot but I felt the term was apt for Sheridan's performance. She is SO fun and sassy... so engaging... then so hurt and vulnerable... and these are the tasks of actors and certainly in one person shows that demand a range of emotions and levels, that's probably expected... but if you're asking what I saw... I saw a master performance that dragged me inside emotionally and left me in awe of the actresses ability.

And I think Suzie Miller is an incredible crafts-woman. Her dialog is so rich with genuine vernacular, but also with legal terms that I don't personally understand but started to understand through her usage. Her creation of a flawed, almost arrogant but at all times likeable character is no mean feat and when the big hits come... what happens to Tessa, and then the experience of the courtcase... the room seemed unitedly stunned with emotion by the end. God I envy her brevity with dialog and clever plotting.

I do not in any way wish to diminish the work of the director and other creatives, but I felt the combination of Miller's script and Harbridge's performance complemented each other six ways to Sunday. There were plenty of Standing O's at the end of the play and it's subject matter was truly moving and stayed with... well certainly me but I suspect a great deal of the audience.

I am a sucker for two word play titles in latin (IYKYK) but irrespective of that, I liked this play so much that i think many of the renowned and established "great plays" will have their jobs cut out for them to move me more.

Could it work in Goulburn? It's worked in over 50 countries so abso-bloody-lutely. 

The version I have been referring to is currently showing at the Ros Packer Theatre from 3 June to 21 June 2026, and is presented by the Sydney Theatre Company.


Featured Post

LETTERS TO LINDY - Alana Valentine

I saw this play last night at the Lieder Theatre and liked it a lot. It's a strong and provocative piece of theatre and it was very well...