Search This Blog

Popular Posts

Showing posts with label regret. Show all posts
Showing posts with label regret. Show all posts

Sunday, 7 June 2026

THE CRUCIBLE - Arthur Miller


I feel very fortunate to have studied "The Crucible" back in Year 10 and again for the HSC in Year 12. I thought then, and have continued to think that it is in my top three favourite pieces of literature of all time... along with "Catcher in the Rye" and "Catch 22" (something about starting with the letter C perhaps). And I have seen the Daniel Day-Lewis movie since, but aside from that, haven't looked back in on the work as either a piece of writing or a performance. So I've anticipated going back to this play and seeing if I felt it still stands up.

In a word... Yes.

In its original context, Arthur Miller wrote this as a searing indictment of the Communist "witch hunt" being conducted by Senator Joe McCarthy and the House Un-American Activities Committee. Even a hint of having communist tendencies, or sympathies, or even conversations ... or not even that, even the hint or suggestion of any of those things could call you before the Committee. People were required to name names, and the pressure on careers and the potential for incarceration was such that people were encouraged into even making up names, and falsely pointing the finger at other parties... often innocent parties... to ensure their own safety.

And a great way to provide an analogy for these metaphoric witch hunts was through a story about the actual witch hunts of Salem in 15th century America. It's great grist for the dramatic mill, and Miller didn't simply take the vague idea of the witch trials but his researched delivered a story based on the actual names and specifics of a brief but disgraceful chain of events that resulted in 30 people were found guilty of witchcraft and 19 of those hanged. The use of real names and real outcomes adds an even more sickening depth to the story.

So let's get to the play.

The Crucible

It's the late 1600s in puritan America and the town of Salem is a particularly pious and publicly Christian community. And, as luck would have it, it's a time when a number of crop and animal related issues occurred. Work of the devil? Let's put that on hold.

It's also a time in which some of the young and allegedly head strong girls and young women of the community have been capering and dancing in the woods at night (oh my stars!). Some have even made daring statements about being able to create poultices and potions with profound effects. Which leads to more base level naturist experimenting, and then to accusations of witch craft against others and so on.

So, with crops, and herds, and even newborn births experiencing a statistically higher than usual rate of failure, some scientifically challenged but religiously enhanced members of the community, particularly the more pious ones, are quick to attribute these outcomes to witches. It couldn't be nature... God wouldn't forsake them... it must be the devil. And from there, evidential outcomes weren't even essential. Accusations began to be accepted as proof, and even accusations of strangeness, or difference, or insufficient church attendance were levied at people and weaponised.

Into this situation stumbles average-joe farmer, John Proctor. In the midst of the "you're a witch" hysteria sweeping the town, John's wife Elizabeth Proctor (or Goody Proctor, short for Goodwife) sacks a young maid, Abigail Williams, who it is subsequently revealed John had slept with while his wife suffered a lengthy illness. John admits this to his wife, and his remorse at this out of character lapse and his complete self-disgust, and that might have been an end to it. Abigail is sacked but still harbours feelings for Proctor, mixed with a will for revenge.

But as the story starts, ten year old Betty Parris lies in bed, dreadfully ill and being tended to by the families West Indian slave Tituba. Betty's father, local preacher Samuel Parris had busted Betty along with some other towns girls and Tituba dancing naked in the forest and involved in some pagan practice. Preacher Parris puts one and one together... and he questions the ringleader of the girls, his own niece Abigail Williams, who denies all allegations. The preacher isn't buying it and brings in first witchcraft expert and Puritan preacher Reverend John Hale to investigate, and then as the situation careens out of control, Judge John Hathorne and Deputy Governor Thomas Danforth.

There are a lot of engaging story threads running through the play as it gains momentum. Their is Abigail’s desire not to be found out for exaggerations and false witness, and so she orchestrates an apparently convincing display alongside other girls in court that apparently demonstrates how they were being controlled by spirits, and specifically those controlled by Tituba. Tittuba, threatened with the blame for all, initially holds strong to her truth that she had no involvement before pressure leads her to say what the court wishes to hear.

There are many other story elements but I’m rushing this a bit. The one that is central to my appreciation of the play is John Proctor, having realised he has fallen short in his own measure of integrity, that when offered a chance of freedom if only he’d sign a document alleging false claims against others, that he could not put his names to lies… even though making that stand would see him killed.

The versions I saw

Because I’m a bit rushed I’ll limit these descriptions. The two pro-shot versions I saw were surprising different given they worked from the same script. One of the key differences were the portrayals by the two actors… both very enjoyable but with significantly different choices.

The 2014 version from the Old Vic starred Richard Armitage as Proctor in a production that earned the show Best Revival at the Olivier awards, and earned the lead best Actor. It’s a very powerful and brooding delivery, probably in keeping with many previous portrayals. Armitage’s Proctor is incredibly conflicted and over-wrought and the entire production carries a tone and a sound design that keeps it all feeling dark and foreboding.

Australia’s own (how I love saying that) Brendan Cowell took the lead in the 2023 production filmed at the Olivier Theatre production at the National Theatre. Cowell strips the role back and delivers a more put upon everyman, perhaps less dramatic and powerful and more an average man stumbling his way towards a moral decision. This version in general… and I’m not entirely sure of what elements contributed to this… seemed less ethereal and a slightly more easy to follow rendition of the script. Just a vibe. And Abigail in this version seemed less assured controller of events and more young woman caught up in her own lies and trying to panic-survive with ad hoc contrived solutions.

Both VERY good versions… I’d suggest watching both if you can.

My thoughts

While the writing and original performance of this play has a historical context in which it resonates particularly poignantly, it still hits (unfortunately) in the present day.

Hysteria, both genuine and performative, is used to sway public opinion and even legal results.

Mythical solutions (witchcraft in this case but in contemporary times, xenophobic stereotypes and minority blame attachment to name a few) are given as explanations to appease broad sections of the public while offering a blame and a scapegoat.

Related to that, authorities seek populist solutions, even ones they know to be untrue or flawed, as a way retain their positions and power.

And the better-late-than-never heroism of John Proctor… the decision to make a stand and live up to his ideals at great cost… is still a potent moral signpost especially in any period of tough times when rights are eroded and unreasonable punishments are meted out.

As I said, I am especially lucky to have studied this twice during secondary school as it gave me a guided tour through the themes, but I’d like to think any reader or audience member could make those connections through their own viewing or reading of the play.

Is it’s message timeless? Maybe. It is certainly as relevant today as when it was written, and who can say if that will continue. Is it still one of the great plays. I haven’t changed my mind… this is still one of the greatest plays I have seen, read or studied. While it covers a past event, its portrayal of an even older event help to unmoor it from a fixed point in time so that it remains an allegory to any time in which “witch-hunts”, scapegoats, mob mentality and hysteria take root.

I realise that there is a play called “John Proctor is the Villain” in which the character is re-evaluated, with special consideration to the fact he was a predator and child abuser for starters. Well, he was, wasn’t he. Can’t argue with that. I haven’t seen the show and don’t know much about it other than my guesses, so I can’t really argue or agree with the points it makes. But I understand the central idea of that play and agree the central character could do with a bit of post-modern revisiting and deconstruction and I do not seek to defend him or justify his bad acts because of his final good deeds. And of course it’s worth remembering "The Crucible" this is a fictionalised depiction of real-life characters and real-life events.

So, WITHOUT focusing on John  Proctor (real or fictional) per se, the trope of a flawed person finding their integrity at the last is not new. I think it was even borrowed from this work and used in stories like the French film “The Return of Martin Guerre” and its American retelling “Sommersby” in which a flawed man returns home, faking to be someone else, and then making a decision to be put to death as a good man rather than live as the bad man he was. It’s French so it’s complex, but you get the gist. One grand heroic act as a means to redemption. And that ELEMENT of the story remains powerful and still rings true even if more thorough assessments of Proctor indicate he was considerably more than just a little flawed.

Miller’s decision to tackle a contemporary problem with a piece of work that endangered his career has in it some echoes of John Proctor’s decision to make an integrity based stand. I suspect the very people he was critiquing weren’t even fully aware this piece was about them. While I have already stated that “All My Sons” showed Miller’s capacity for dialog and intricate dovetailing plotlines, I feel this work will continue to attract more and greater currency due to its ongoing application to modern but seemingly unchanging times.

I’ve rushed the end of this blog a bit, particularly the summation of the play, because real life is dragging me elsewhere, but I do want to emphasise this IS one of the truly great plays and would not only work anywhere (including of course Goulburn) but I believe at any time.

Materials accessed

“The Crucible” - script (1953). Available many places but commercially and for free including this link from the Internet Archive.

“The Crucible” - pro-shot video (2014). Available by subscription on Digital Theatre.

“The Crucible” - pro-shot video (2023). Available by subscription on National Theatre at Home.

Thursday, 15 January 2026

THREE SISTERS - Anton Chekhov

 


As my journey through some of the Great Plays of all time continues, I am becoming increasingly aware of the role of taste. And obviously it’s not something restricted to the theatre. For everyone sitting down for a night of watching the Godfather, someone else is watching Happy Gilmore. For everyone looking forward to a night on the cans, someone else is anticipating a quiet night with a pinot noir. And none of that is to imply an innate sense of worthiness to these choices. Your favourite ice cream might be chocolate, or strawberry… or licorice. Dealers choice.

And none of that paragraph relates specifically to “Three Sisters” except as a way of flagging that to date Chekhov’s work has not grabbed me as I hoped it would. And so, as a disclaimer, now that I have a slightly better experiential catalog of Chekhov’s plays behind me and offering the same apologies for my own personal tastes and possible insufficiencies… I’m still not there with Chekhov yet.

There’s a TV sitcom I’m very fond of, “Seinfeld”, which has been described, even by its own creators as “the show about nothing.” The show was very much situational and, especially in earlier episodes, not super big on dramatic plot points. But very funny nonetheless.

It’s a criticism that some (like I) might level at some Chekhov plays… and again, no doubt that statement is in some way a reflection of my tastes and capacities). I really did enjoy some of the philosophical musings expressed in some very clever pieces of dialog. But (and this may be a product of my available time), but finishing this play was a bit of a punish I find it hard to complete and I wasn’t overly motivated to doing so. Also the version I saw was pretty bloody flat despite some pretty handy actors.

But I don’t want to be guilty of shit-canning this play just because I didn’t enjoy it all that much. I know that all of Chekhov’s works are revered, widely enjoyed and performed with impressive regularity to this day and so, even though very few people will read this blog, I feel a duty to treat this play with the respect time and overwhelming popularity have earned it. So here goes.

What it’s about

Would it shock you to know that the story is about three sisters? Thought not. And there’s a brother two, suffering from the same referencing marginalisation experienced by Dumas fourth musketeer, D’Artagnan. There are also a bunch of soldiers and other men and women in key roles, and a few extras for good measure.

Written and set as the 18th century was giving way to the 19th, the play is set against the backdrop of changes that are coming. Sisters Irina (youngest), Masha (ironically the Jan Brady of the bunch) and Olga (the eldest), along with brother Andrei used to live in Moscow. They have been living a tree change for the last 11 years but long to return.

Olga is a spinster, headmistress and matriarch/acting mother figure of the brood. Masha, the middle child, is married to latin-teaching Kulgiyn but is afflicted with the seven year itch (literally) and falls for and has an affair with Lt Colonel Vershinin (and she’s not the only one cheating around). Youngest sister Irina isn’t in love with anyone but when she realises they aren’t going back to Moscow, agrees to marry Baron Tuzenbach but in a twist… nope I’ll let you discover what happens there.

And brother Andrei, adored by his sisters, is a good, decent and worthy chap, bogged down by indecision. He marries the seemingly shy and quiet Natasha (who his sisters don’t like) but boy does she show here true colours as the story continues.

There’s also Solyony (the nutcase), old Dr Chebutykin, soldier and amateur photographer Fedotik, another soldier called Rode, Anfisa the aged house maid (treated well by the girls but not so much by Natasha) and Ferepont, another aged character, who chimes in with random comments.

And in reading that, I have to admit I LIKE those bones. That’s a well constructed cast of characters, with lots of opportunity for story telling. But I’ll come back to that.

The Themes

I guess we all relive past mistakes, recurring flaws and favoured highlights a bit. That’s definitely true for Chekhov. Many of the same themes and plot ideas show up again that are present in “The Seagull” and “Uncle Vanya.” As a fan of the whole Rocky franchise (well not Rocky V… that one was poo) I can appreciate the subtle and even obvious reuse of story ideas, but I think when you didn’t love it the first time around, the impact of repetition hits differently.

“Three Sisters” (and the other Chehov’s I’ve read and witness) are a bit uneventful and I appreciate that’s the appeal for some. But I felt that the ongoing introspection and navel gazing, used to the degree it is, takes a toll. I appreciate contemplation as much as the next guy. Maybe moreso. But I think the existential ennui has been covered. Asked and answered, your honour. Move along.

The tone is also stuck in some mid-tone plateau. Neither dramatic, nor funny, nor sad, nor aggravating, nor evocative. I have also seen and enjoyed lots of tragic and sad plays, often operating with a degree of light and shade, but I felt this didn’t grab my heart and break it so much as suffocate it like a heavy cloud of pervasive pessimism. Again, nothing wrong with bringing the darker and more  complex emotions… all a matter of taste. And like a cake, I see the flour, sugar and eggs, I possibly didn’t go for the specific mix.

Another of Chekhov’s go-tos, unrequited love, takes a central role again, paired with unfaithfulness in marriage and relationships. Both come up so often in Chekhov plays that I kind of feeling like taking the good playwright aside and saying “Anton… Tony… mate. If I could have a quick word. How’s things at home?” But anyway, here they are again. And not just once. And a gun, of course, with a significant plot point of its own (albeit offstage)

Other recurring themes… the monotony and lack of fulfillment of middle class provincial life is front and centre again. Also the unbearable heaviness of being, what have I done with my life and what is there left I could do, the loss of prestige.

On the stage (or at least on screen)

The only copy I could find of this is from that wonderful storehouse of the great plays “BBC Play of The Month” - a “show” that ran from 1965 to 1983 (literally the year I was born until the year I completed Year 12… but it’s not about me!). This series covered 121 plays in full, including MANY of the greatest plays of all time, and one of those was “Three Sisters”.

This version featured a few actors I’d seen before… a very young Anthony Hopkins, Joss Ackland (the Diplomatic Immunity guy from “Lethal Weapon”), Michele Dotrice (the wife from “Some Mothers do Ave em”) and Janet Suzman. 

The BBC has kicked many goals in this space but this play fell very flat and maybe that has biased my enjoyment? I really had to push myself over several sittings to finish this. And now it sounds like I’m calling this performance bad. I just don’t think it delivered particularly well at some key moments and on some key lines. But it’s available on Youtube, so judge for yourself. 

As with a few plays/movies I’ve seen for this project (particularly Ibsen’s “Hedda Gabler”) early impressions changed dramatically thanks to one sensational performance. It could very be that a combination of a strong version of this and my growing familiarity with the script and characters will turn my opinion around considerable.

Last bits

If I saw this as my first Chekhov, and not my third, I may have enjoyed it more. The repetitiveness of central themes didn’t give me the “well that’s new” hit that I was hoping for.

I liked many bits of dialogs, particularly some relating to how we don’t get to be happy now, that’s for future generations, although some times I wanted to yell out “For the love of God, the lower classes are REALLY struggling around you and mostly your lives aren’t too bad. Please, SOMEONE, appreciate that.”

I got frustrated by the inertia and self-imposed lack of agency of the characters, a lack of willingness to change their situations, but I get that that was the very thing Chekhov was trying to show. I think.

The play wraps up clearly. The time comes for closing books and long last looks must end (To Sergei, with Love?) but I thought the end message, though a consistent and succinct rendering of a key theme, was a bit morose and limited. What’s there to live for? Nothing. It’s also a bit like the end of “Uncle Vanya” although in that Sonya imbued it with a bit of nobility. Here, I felt Albert Camus and Jean-Paul Sartre would have exchanged knowing smiles and added “HE gets it.”

I think I’m being a bit harsh, but I really didn’t love it. Again, I think my appreciation of this will grow with further encounters with the play. But I’m not quite there yet.

Materials accessed:

Featured Post

LETTERS TO LINDY - Alana Valentine

I saw this play last night at the Lieder Theatre and liked it a lot. It's a strong and provocative piece of theatre and it was very well...