Search This Blog

Popular Posts

Showing posts with label denial. Show all posts
Showing posts with label denial. Show all posts

Saturday, 18 April 2026

ALL MY SONS - Arthur Miller

 


From the outset, I have to say I really enjoyed this play. I had next to no knowledge of it before viewing (I watched two versions of this and didn't read the play) and so I experienced it without expectations. I also should probably confess that before I started this ridiculous 100 Great Plays in 365 Days, my favourite play was "The Crucible", also by Miller, so I was a bit nervous about whether I'd enjoy any other of his works. I needn't have worried.

Before I get into this post, I'll take a brief segue, which I think I'm safe to do because I doubt anyone is actually reading this blog series. I've looked back on these blogs and they are a bit all over the place. Some focus on the script, some on a performance (or several performances). Is it a review of the script, or the writer, or the performance? Sometimes all of the above. Reading back through the blog posts, I feel they don't live up to the personal quality standards of theatrical reviews I have previously written. With community theatre, I don't make much mention of anything negative and try to draw out the positive aspects I most enjoyed, sharing any insights and impacts I might have experienced. And, while in this blog I don't avoid detailing the elements I don't love and I feel fine with that, the actual central concept of the blogs seems a little vague and unclear and I was a bit disappointed that the style and standard and intent of what I wrote differed a lot from post to post.

But as this is a theatrical journey, I think it's ok if I figure some of these things on the run. While I will still try to draw out themes and ideas (and performances and staging where they stand out to me), I think the overarching point of my writing the blogs is to process my thoughts which seems to be aided by the written word, and that these posts are not reviews per se, they are impressions of how a play hits me, what appealed, what didn't and why... fully aware that individual productions can give very different experiences. I'm trying to be a theatrical archeologist, uncovering things that are new to me, even if they are already well, known to others. So these blogs are not reviews per se, they are just my experiences of encountering works I'm not familiar with. 

I'm also trying, unsuccessfully, trying to find ways of shortening these down... mostly because the time needed to write them is chewing into my play reading and watching time considerably. Fingers crossed. Now back to the play.

All my sons

The idea for the play came to Miller from an idea suggested by his mother. Some owners and leaders of a manufacturing business that made parts for aircraft became aware of some faulty parts, but sold them to the US defence force anyway. Planes fell from the sky and many American service men died. That provides the story frame, although the individuals, their conversations and their interactions are fictional.

The play touches on themes of family v doing the right thing, obligation, materialism, guilt, denial, war and morality. It's a very satisfactory meal. Aside from the great plotting and interactions between characters, two main things contributed to my enjoyment of this play. Miller is a gifted dialogist. and I was fortunate enough to see two outstanding productions (that I'll get to later).

Regarding the former, I found that Miller's character conversations hit home as more realistic to me than many of the playwrights I've been reading in this series. His dialog (again, at least to me) was more pithy, more punchy, and while there was a sufficient amount to set tone and mood, he didn't bog down there which I've felt happened with a few other playwrights. He gets on with the story and the various plot elements he drops have few red herrings and connect together for a powerful conclusion.

I'm going to try and avoid spoilers because I believe this play works best with some surprises up its sleeve... but the characters include the father and family figure head Joe Keller, who runs the plant and was briefly imprisoned before being exonerated, Kate (his wife) who is mourning her oldest son (Larry) that was reported missing presumed dead, which she doesn't believe. Kate loves her family, but retains some hostility towards Joe and on several triggered occasions succumbs to a lack of control and anger. 

Chris Keller, the surviving son, idolises his brother and his parents, and has fallen in love with Annie Deever, who had been Larry's girl before Larry went "missing" three years ago. Chris believes she feels the same way. Annie is also the daughter of Joe's former friend and colleague Steve Deever who was found guilty of the matters Joe was cleared of, setting up something of a Montague and Capulets, or Hatfield and McCoys situation.

Arriving later in the play is Annie's brother, George, who grew up as a close friend of Chris. He believed that his father was guilty of the crimes he was convicted of, but has come to believe his dad was innocent and carrying the blame of other guilty parties. There are five other characters, neighbours and friends, who also share the stage.

Again, avoiding too many reveals, what I most liked about the play was the intricacy of the intertwined relationships, the slow reveal of key bits of information, the hints of something not being quite right in elevated conversations in which Joe or Kate seemed somehow amplified. and the appropriately limited use of the characters with lesser parts... none of their appearances or dialog wasted, all contributing without pulling focus.

If I haven't made it clear yet, I REALLY liked this play... and maybe it's because I have been hiding beneath a theatrical rock that I hadn't heard much about the play and so it snuck up on me like some sort of hidden gem.  

I was also very relieved. Since many of the highly regarded plays by the highly regarded playwrights didn't do very much for me (not all of them... loved "Our Town" and quite liked a few others), I was starting to think there was something wrong with my ability to appreciate revered works. But I enjoyed the first production of this that I saw this so much, I was excited to know I had another great version up my sleeve, and neither disappointed.

The versions I saw

The first version I watched was from the 2019 London Revival performed at the Old Vic in London. The star-studded turn included, among others, Bill Pullman as Joe, Sally Field as Kate, Jenna Coleman as Annie and Colin Morgan as Chris. Pullman was fine, and the others I felt were exceptional. Sally fields grief was palpable, her mood turns, always triggered by fear of things hidden coming to light, were gripping. Former Doctor Who companion Jenna Coleman, perhaps as a result of her fake time travelling experience, slid effortlessly into the role of a young woman in the 1940s, and her reactions and confusion to the changing moods and attitudes around her hit all the right sympathetic nerves. But I thought Colin Morgan, who I know almost nothing about except that he played the title role in the Merlin TV series, was exceptional. Of all of the characters, he had the most dramatic arc to draw and I felt he nailed the optimistic affable everyman that descended into a distraught young man tortured by revelations exactly as Miller devised it. A great performance, with a very realistic reproduction of a backyard leading into the back of a house as it's staged set piece, that you can see on the National Theatre at Home subscription service.

The other version I saw was also very very good. It also recreated the same scene setting in a very similar style (lighting seemed a bit too harsh on the actors faces at times but it looked great). This was the 2010 production staged at the Apollo Theatre in the West End. It starred David Suchet and Zoe Wanamaker (both from the TV series Poirot) as Joe and Kate respectively, with Jemima Rooper as Annie, and Stephen Campbell Moore as Chris. I have to say, I've never seen a lot of range in my limited views of David Suchet as he has mostly played serious, taciturn roles, but his performance in this was avuncular and full of joy. I thought his was a stronger, more layered performance than Pullman's. I think he also hit the emotional sweet spots in the more dramatic moments too, partly I imagine because of how well he'd delivered the lighter side. The other actors were all very good too. This version can be seen on the Digital Theatre subscription streaming service and, honestly, you could see either version of this and be equally as entertained and moved.

My thoughts

While it's not about a very well known true story, I think the fact that Miller had a frame suggested by a true story helped him guide his ship. This was his second play and his first, "The man who had all the Luck" had flopped on Broadway, lasting only four nights. he was so dispirited he said he'd try one more show and if that didn't work, he'd give it away. This was that show, and thankfully he didn't give it away or we would have been deprived of not only this show but the rest of his catalog of shows.

Again, I totally enjoyed this. The family tones and relationships felt familiar, the difficulty in absorbing new information about loved ones and trying to figure out how to react didn't seem at all performative, and the dramatic finish hit hard because all of the hard work had been done in engaging the audience and bringing them irresistibly to to that point. 

But most of all the dialog. So many quotes that showed a great ear for original, interesting writing. Here's just a couple of phrases that I really liked, showcasing his touch for the light and comic, and also the ability to hit the mark with both barrels.

- When Chris asks his dad (Joe) for the book review of the newspaper, and his dad replies but you don't read any books, Chris replies "I like to keep abreast of my ignorance." 

- Or when Joe says “I’m his father and he’s my son, and if there’s something bigger than that I’ll put a bullet in my head.” 

And there's another quote near the end that gives greater depth to the title of the show.

Overall, I totally enjoyed this. No notes from me. It's a great show, and one I'd like to see in person, anywhere.

Materials accessed:

  • "All my Sons" - script (1946). Available for free at many sites online, including this version from Maitland Repertory Theatre.
  • "All my Sons" - pro-shot video (2010). Produced at the Apollo Theatre and available to view by subscription on the Digital Theatre streaming service.
  • "All my Sons" - pro-shot video (2019). Produced at the Old Vic theatre and available to view by subscription on the National Theatre at Home streaming service.

Please note... there are other versions that can be viewed for free on Youtube but I have not accessed those.


Wednesday, 18 February 2026

LONG DAY'S JOURNEY INTO NIGHT - Eugene O'Neill

 


Eugene O'Neill is the only playwright to win a fourth Pulitzer Prize for Drama four times, and this is the play that won the fourth time, as well as the Tony Award for Best Play. It's also regarded by many critics as his greatest work, and one of the greatest American plays of the 20th century.

And it's quite good. On a personal level I very much appreciated that, coming in under 3 hours, it's much shorter than the last two plays of his that I watched.

I don't know that I'd call it one of the greatest American plays of the 20th century but as I'm becoming increasingly aware, individual mileage can vary greatly. And I have to factor in my reactions are specifically to the 1962 movie I watched. But the fact that it won both the Tony and the Pulitzer attests to a significant amount of critical appreciation .

A bit of background... O'Neill wrote this play in 1939 and continued to revise it until 1941. Because of its particularly auto-biographical self-revelatory, he didn't want it ever to be performed and didn't even want it published however he eventually supplied it to publishers in 1945 conditionally that it could not be published until 25 years after his death. 

O'Neill died eight years later (1953) and shortly after his death his wife demanded that his publishers rescind those instructions and publish the play, which against their wishes they did. From first completing the play until publication represents a gap of 17 years, so it was a long play's journey into publication.

The journey

Another O'Neill play with a poetic title, the Long Day in question is the setting for the play. The whole thing happens over one day as a family of two sons along with their mother and father gather at a holiday home in Connecticut.

The premise is that, gathered together, the four are forced to confront their flaws, their unresolved interpersonal issues

For mine, the greatest strength of the play is the poetry of the language used by O'Neill, especially in the longish reflections and expositions. There are so many beautifully worded lines, and also some clever witty ones. One of my favourite lines from Edmund's father to him after being accused of being cheap and offering to send him to a cut-price sanatorium to treat his tuberculosis/consumption.

"You can go to any place you choose, never mind what it costs. Any place... I can afford. Any place... within reason."

Another thing that comes through strongly is the awkwardness of some usually-avoided painful and even devastating conversations. The play represents 24 hours of soul-searching and soul-bearing, touching on a number of taboos and family secrets and confessions, including drug use, failed career options, internal family blames and hostility and mental health (not specifically stated but seemingly intertwined with Mary's addiction). And I also quite liked the way O'Neill directed traffic, creating moments for characters in different combinations to have conversations specific to each relationship.

Aside from the length (again, better than some of O'Neill's marathons but still quite hefty) my biggest misgiving is the repetition of the number of times a character will express their extreme anger to another, then sort it out and apologise, only to then repeat the cycle again. It happens a lot. I think the intent is to show that families are repetitious and go through the same actions, and same conversations over and over again. And that's true. I just felt O'Neill continued beyond the point of having established that point.

There are some profound statements and engaging exchanges...Eugene's late night discussion with his father helps him understand his dad a lot better. My favourite conversations is the late night conversation between the brothers... a little less recrimination than some of the other scene couples and quite a bit of real connection and genuine sharing between to brothers who happened to to be best friends who "love each others guts," although even that features some mean mood swings.

Clearly one of the most praised playwrights of the 20th century needs no advice that I can offer, but if I was offering advice, this would have felt far stronger to me if (a) a lot of the dramatic moments were repeated with little addition to the play and (b) if it didn't lean so close to melodrama with the rapid emotional swings.

The versions I saw

I watched the 1962 film starring Katherine Hepburn, Ralph Richardson, Jason Robards and Dean Stockwell. Obviously acting styles and direction have changed over the years, but even allowing for that I found this enjoyable... yet somewhat overacted. And not by the actors you'd possibly suspect.

I did like the camera work, sets and lighting a lot... closeups are used particularly well. 

Ralph Richardson delivered a powerful version of James but I thought he added just a little too much sauce, especially in the most dramatic moments. Even allowing for the fact his character is meant to be an actor of modest ability with a love for Shakespeare, I thought his delivery at times was overly melodramatic and attemptedly Shakespearean beyond what was required.

Katherine Hepburn covers a wide range of emotions but the switch up between deliriously happy, to deeply sad or angry is whiplash fast and you could do yourself an injury trying to keep up. As with Ralph Richardson's performance, I'm sure she and the director interpreted the script that way and no doubt thought it might be an Oscar-winning performance (and it did earn her a nomination) but I felt she was cranked up to 11 to a distracting degree.

Jason Robards isn't someone who has ever struck me as having great range but I thought he was quite good in this and spot on for the character (although as with the others the mercurial swings take some absorbing), but for me the highlight was a very young Dean Stockwell. I probably first encountered him in "Quantum Leap" and later saw him in other works, but in a cast with far greater experience then he, I thought he stood out with a nuanced, emotional and touching portrayal.

Misgivings aside, this film is well worth a watch. The final scene is an exceptionally good piece of cinematography, all gathered in a room and realising they may have made no progress and be stuck exactly where they started, extreme closeups then pulled back away to indicate the discussions and arguments continue on.

The other version I saw I liked a lot more. It was the pro-shot video of the Apollo Theatre production of 2012 with Laurie Metcalf (from Roseanne and a whole lot of other things) and Poirot's David Suchet. The acting is uniformly stronger... less jerky emotional switches (even if the text remains the same) and the relationships between the characters come off more realistic. It felt, to coin the cliche, more real and more powerful as a result.

Final words

It's a good play, and deserves to be understood in context of how novel a narrative it was for its time, and how closely it reflected the life experience of its playwright.

I don't know if the lengthy gap (16 years) between this work and O'Neill's last published work "A Touch of the Poet," added to the prestige and nostalgia and fondness for the gifted playwright. More likely the critics and audiences of the time, and many since, just hold to a slightly different evaluation than me.  

This could certainly be performed locally... in fact I could definitely seeing local performers wanting to do it and local audiences wanting to see it. My only real criticisms relate to length, repetition and the potential of overacting the quick emotional swings. I'm probably splitting hairs.

Well done, Mr O'Neill. Nicely written.

Materials Accessed:

  • "Long Day's Journey into Night" - script (1939). There are several places you can access a free copy online. Here's one from the Internet Archive.
  • "Long Day's Journey into Night" - movie (1962). Available to view for free on Youtube.
  • "Long Day's Journey into Night" - pro-shot video (2012). Available for streaming by subscription on Digital Theatre.
  • "Long Day's Journey into Night" - filmed play (2017). Available to view for free on Youtube.



Featured Post

LETTERS TO LINDY - Alana Valentine

I saw this play last night at the Lieder Theatre and liked it a lot. It's a strong and provocative piece of theatre and it was very well...